|
Post by antharro on Jun 28, 2010 21:53:01 GMT
Not sure if this should be here or in trains technical...
As I was out and about today, I spent some time on the central from Greenford to Shephard's Bush. Watching the trains going the other way, I noticed that they really aren't in the greatest condition now.
- Rust/corrosion around the windows. (Really noticable on some units). - Paintwork looking a bit shabby, definitely in need of a wash at least! - Generally looking a bit run down and in need of some TLC. - Graffiti removal making the paintwork look even worse. - Even the duct tape on the cab ends was looking flaky and worn!
Inside, while mostly free of litter, the seat covers looked worn and there was a definite layer of grime on the surfaces behind the seats where the air vents are. Even the panelling by the adverts and line map looked as if it had seen better days. (And if replaced should be in a slightly lighter colour, imo!)
Is a refresh for these trains in the pipeline? I'd like to think so as I quite like them, but I suspect what will happen in the current economic climate is they'll receive the bare minimum maintenance to keep them in working order and rolling, then when the economy picks up and there's more money around, TfL will say they're not reliable enough (due to the lack of maintenance) so they'll be scrapped and replaced with new trains.
Feels to me like the mechanicals and the chassis are ok, it's the body that's falling apart!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 28, 2010 22:29:30 GMT
There was talk way back in 2006 from metronet that the 92 stock on the central aswell as the W&C would be refurbished, but of course we all know what happened to them... I agree with you, they do need a refit, even just a deep clean to the interior would brighten those trains up alot.
|
|
|
Post by plasmid on Jun 29, 2010 8:16:50 GMT
You need to spend more time on the Central Line...if you do that you would have noticed the following...
Mechanicals would be okay...with £150 million spent on new bogies (look at some trains underneath and they will have new kit on half of the trains).
Duct tape on the cab ends is in the process of being replaced (alot of cabs have this done already).
Resealing the windows to prevent rain leaking into the cars and ruining the seats (seats will not be replaced until this has been done). Paintwork is being tidied up in that area too.
Like it or not that is about as good as they are going to get. And if they have spent £150 million on new bogies then you can sure say you will not be getting any new stock any time soon.
edit: just makes me wonder would it not have been cheaper over time to just replace the fleet if the sum of £150 million has been spent on new siemens bogies?
|
|
|
Post by Chris W on Jun 29, 2010 15:23:04 GMT
An old thread (practically a year old) can be found within the Central Line section HEREIts a 12 page thread, so please don't add to it (just this new thread started by antharro above), but it covers issues re tape around cabs/leaks and condition of the stock... not to mention why people hate them
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 30, 2010 8:26:39 GMT
Word going around that we will be getting a refurb for 2012 and that there is already a refurbed cab on one unit though I've not had the pleasure of sitting in it yet. Once again with money short and a lot more pressing matters on other lines I'm not holding my breath for this.
|
|
Chris M
Global Moderator
Forum Quizmaster
Always happy to receive quiz ideas and pictures by email or PM
Posts: 19,770
|
Post by Chris M on Jun 30, 2010 8:42:14 GMT
I'd have thought that there wouldn't be time to do any significant refubishment on the entire fleet between now and 2012. A deep clean of the passenger saloons (dunno if the cabs need this as well or not) would be good and should be doable I'd have thought. Comparatively inexpensive too probably.
|
|
|
Post by antharro on Jun 30, 2010 12:51:28 GMT
plasmid - Perhaps I'm not reading your post as intended, but you seem to be slightly hostile? I did say in my first post that I thought the mechanicals were ok, it was the bodies that were showing signs of wear! I'm glad to hear things are getting done; the units I saw when I was out and about looked decidedly shabby. £150m on bogies seems an awful lot of money, especially when you take into account the Northern Line trains were £6m each... (source: the previous 1992ts thread linked to by Chris W) ...but then, I like the 92ts so it's good to hear they're getting some TLC, and I'd bet there'd be more costs involved than just the price of the train if they were replaced! aslefshrugged I'd heard something about them getting refurbed for 2012, but I can't for the life of me remember where I'd heard it. Wasn't on this forum tho. I also can't see where the money's going to come from for this.
|
|
|
Post by plasmid on Jun 30, 2010 17:58:18 GMT
antharro - Apologies for your misunderstanding but I'm not being hostile at all, it's just the way I worded it! The Siemens bogies are grey in colour, I keep seeing new ones on trains all the time so they are being installed at a fair rate, though I can't tell if they are only doing 2 or 4 carriages at a time! aslefshrugged - the refurbished unit you saw wouldn't have been the Chancery Lane derailed unit would it? If so that explains the cleanliness of the unit. That was refurbished in-house I think.
|
|
|
Post by antharro on Jun 30, 2010 19:32:01 GMT
plasmid - Glad to hear it, my mistake, sorry!
|
|
|
Post by superteacher on Jun 30, 2010 20:09:29 GMT
antharro - Apologies for your misunderstanding but I'm not being hostile at all, it's just the way I worded it! The Siemens bogies are grey in colour, I keep seeing new ones on trains all the time so they are being installed at a fair rate, though I can't tell if they are only doing 2 or 4 carriages at a time! aslefshrugged - the refurbished unit you saw wouldn't have been the Chancery Lane derailed unit would it? If so that explains the cleanliness of the unit. That was refurbished in-house I think. The Chancery Lane unit was repaired nearly 7 years ago - you'd never be able to tell it from the others now. I think the one you saw was 91171, which was the unit involved in the Bethnal Green derailment - it looks much tidier than the other units, has no tape around the cab etc.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 1, 2010 7:32:11 GMT
Antharro - I first heard about the pre 2012 refurb from a DMT a month ago but nothing more than a rumour at the moment and I think we all know how much rumour and gossip goes on at LUL.
Nick0323 and Superteacher - I was told about the refurb cab by a TOp (a usually reliable one), said it was instantly recognisable as the interior was pristine, so probably not the unit involved in the BEG derail. Don’t know if the refurb included the saloon or just the cab, as I said I haven’t been fortunate enough to give it a try but then there are 170 cabs out there and we only get two or three trains a day, what are the chances?
|
|
|
Post by auxsetreq on Jul 1, 2010 8:45:42 GMT
I've heard similar. TT66 to further reduce the service so trains can be taken out to be tarted up for the Bor- lympics. Just rumours as you say. 171 inside doesn't appear any different from any other - cab or saloon. Cab I hate the most - 005. The repair to the offside desk is a real botch job..............All in all though, all of 'em are in a right old state and until the morons who deface them are severly dealt with any respray or reglazing will be like pi55ing good money away in the wind...........Oh, and don't get me started on the filthy selfish ^%@#'s who eat stinking fast food in all this heat and in a small enclosed environment then leave the rubbish all over the seats, vents and floors....... ........Time for a food ban methinks. Why not? Other Metros have done it...........
|
|
cso
Posts: 1,043
|
Post by cso on Jul 1, 2010 10:28:44 GMT
Time for a food ban methinks. Why not? Other Metros have done it........... The alcohol ban can not be enforced, so I can't imagine a food ban is going to make much different. I do agree with the previous comment about the seats needing deep cleaned or recovered though!
|
|
|
Post by plasmid on Jul 1, 2010 11:37:51 GMT
@auxsetreq - Are there not spare trains laying around? Everytime I hop on the Jubilee and go past the depot at Stratford there are always at least 10 trains doing nothing!
Mind you though I guess they can't run more trains until the signalling is complete.
Does the Central not have spare trains which may not be required to run a full service with WTT65?
|
|
SE13
In memoriam
RIP 23-Oct-2013
Glorious Gooner
Posts: 9,737
|
Post by SE13 on Jul 1, 2010 12:08:31 GMT
Well, doesn't the Central run 30tph during peak, and about half that during other times, meaning there will be quite a number sat in sidings?
|
|
|
Post by auxsetreq on Jul 1, 2010 12:32:02 GMT
Time for a food ban methinks. Why not? Other Metros have done it........... The alcohol ban can not be enforced, so I can't imagine a food ban is going to make much different. I do agree with the previous comment about the seats needing deep cleaned or recovered though! Since the drinks ban came in, it's nowhere near as bad as it was. So hopefully a food ban might work in a similar way in so much as the smell and litter is reduced. It might make people think that there are others in close proximity to them. I'm sure other customers would appreciate their clothes not stinking of BBQ chicken and all the sauces when using The Tube, especially late at night........but as many stations have fast food outlets on the concourses, like Ealing Bdy, a food ban is just pie-in-the-sky, or in this case a cheese-and-onion-pasty-on-the moquette.......... There was an advertising campaign some years ago that drew criticism because of national stereotyping, so it was dropped. Perhaps something like this might help in the fight to make any refurbed trains not look/smell like they do now.......like a rank mobile fly tip.........
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2010 6:07:21 GMT
Auxsetreq when you say “small enclosed environment” do you mean the saloon or the cab? Picked up from a WHC TOp yesterday at LES WB and when I changed ends at EAB was greeted by an apple core next to the fire extinguisher and a load of pasatchio shells by the footrest. Food ban, yes please!
Nick0323 – can’t comment on Stratford depot, that’s the Jub, but we certainly don’t have a surplus of trains sitting around in depots on the Central during the peak. If they are being refurbed sometime between now and the Olympics then we will have less stock available while it’s being done.
On the state of the exterior paint work one favourite “tagger” spots is the main line shunt west of LES, which the last HAI train does every night except Sunday. I’ve lost count the number of times I’ve done this duty and discovered that there had been a bit of redecoration when I changed ends up the North Neck. I was hoping that they’d lose this move with the new timetable and run the last HAI through the pipe but it appears to still be there so with the summer hols coming up I foresee the cleaners doing a lot of scrubbing.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2010 6:19:39 GMT
Auxsetreq – re. alcohol ban, have to disagree with you, it was effective for the first few months but now it’s just the same as before and the only people who think it’s working are those who believe Boris’s spin doctors.
Weds, NOA, 17:00hrs, I found two empty wine bottles and a crowd of beer cans; hardly last train on a Thursday or Friday night when you expect a bit of a party.
|
|
|
Post by auxsetreq on Jul 2, 2010 6:45:07 GMT
***Auxsetreq when you say “small enclosed environment” do you mean the saloon or the cab? Picked up from a WHC TOp yesterday at LES WB and when I changed ends at EAB was greeted by an apple core next to the fire extinguisher and a load of pasatchio shells by the footrest. Food ban, yes please!***
Both, Aslefshrugged ( great Handle BTW, sooo true ) Some of our colleagues can be a little messy too, I agree, but they don't have time to eat what I observed the other day coming from behind in the saloon. Got to East Acton in the evening peak, bloke got on, and then came the whiff. "'Ere we go, I thought." Got to WC and got out and peered through the window directly behind. Sitting there was some guy eating - Chef's special fried rice and what looked like crispy pork and king prawns in a sweet and sour sauce, chucking it down with chopsticks to boot. So I got on and asked " Scuuuze mate, could you please eat that on the platform 'cos yer stinking the whole train out." He paused and looked aghast that another human being existed and had dared to pop the bubble of his little world. He was good though and to the relief of the other punters closed up the boxes that contained the offensive odours and just sat there........Some of 'em get on first thing, have a banana, wash it down with a Red Bull, and leave both slimy skin and can on the seat, talk about inconsiderate, lazy and selfish............
The morons that have defaced and continue to deface trains, walls and so on should be made to pay for the damage done, and made to clean it up. Send the bailiffs 'round...........
|
|
DWS
every second count's
Posts: 2,487
|
Post by DWS on Jul 2, 2010 8:59:09 GMT
@auxsetreq - Are there not spare trains laying around? Everytime I hop on the Jubilee and go past the depot at Stratford there are always at least 10 trains doing nothing! Mind you though I guess they can't run more trains until the signalling is complete. Does the Central not have spare trains which may not be required to run a full service with WTT65? Trains are in depots off peak for any number of reasons, as you are just passing on a train you may think nothing is going on, but trains are always having some thing done on them
|
|
|
Post by plasmid on Jul 2, 2010 13:15:52 GMT
DWS - This was the morning peak! Sorry I didn't mention in my original post... @ auxsetreq - I agree with your disagreement on food on the tube, I find it annoying especially when travelling during peak hours. Some people's odour is bad enough as it is... aslefshrugged - surely there must be one or two spare trains which do nothing during peak and can be sent off for refurbishment without affecting the timetable? I can't recall how many D stocks went off at once or whether if it was just one!
|
|
|
Post by flippyff on Jul 2, 2010 19:33:41 GMT
I visited the 'Transforming the Tube' exhibition at Aldwych station today, there was a mock up of two tube seats in the new moquette (brain freeze, bet I've spelt that wrong). On the accompanying sign it said that the Central line would be the first to receive it.
Simon
|
|
Ben
fotopic... whats that?
Posts: 4,282
|
Post by Ben on Jul 2, 2010 20:37:41 GMT
The central is chronically under stocked for the service it deserves and should have, and also for the reliability of the 92ts.
The line needs something, but I'm increasingly doubtful its a refurb of the 92s. You can gold plate a brick but it'll never be an ingot. The money spent on the bogies seems a total waste when the line requires new stock in terms of engineering and PR more urgently than the SSR, however a cynic would suggest its just designed to keep them going till money and time is more freely available to replace them totally.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2010 22:38:49 GMT
Ben - The S stock replaces kit that has been in service since 1959, 1968 and 1980. The 09 on the Victoria replaces 68s. With the Picc 73s due to be replaced with 14s but no plans to replace the 72s on the Bloos I think the 92s will be around for a while. I’ll be honest here, I’ve only worked 92s and they really aren’t that bad, apart from the ATP MCB needing a reset about once a day they are pretty reliable.
Nick 0323 – we have cancellations of timetabled WHC- NEP shuttles, T101, T102, T103 etc, on a regular basis. The trains may be in depots but they’re not in any condition to run in service. As for Stratford depot, see my earlier comments, it’s the Jubbley, different line, no idea.
Flippyff – was told by an IOp at my last five day block that the new seats will be a lot lighter weight-wise to make access to the kit underneath a bit easier for us weaklings. Admittedly the marquette is a bit mind blowing, will we all be tripping out too much to isolate faulty compressors?
|
|
|
Post by ruislip on Jul 2, 2010 23:31:40 GMT
Nick 0323 – we have cancellations of timetabled WHC- NEP shuttles, T101, T102, T103 etc, on a regular basis. The trains may be in depots but they’re not in any condition to run in service. As for Stratford depot, see my earlier comments, it’s the Jubbley, different line, no idea. Are these peak or off peak. I've noticed in recent years the increasing use of Newbury Park as a reversing point on the Hainault loop. Back in my days of frequent to sporadic use of the Central, I remember White City shorts running to either Liverpool St or Leytonstone. I've also noticed that Northolt is a reversing point not just during the peaks.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 3, 2010 6:42:41 GMT
Ruislip - we have cancellations during the peak, simply no stock available, though it is nice if the DDM lets us know before you’ve walked all the way into the yard at HAI..
I think there are 5 or 6 WHC – NEP, plus reversers at NOR, DEB, NOA and LES at all times off day or at least there were until tomorrow when the new timetable comes in, haven’t seen what we do on that. I’ll be honest and admit I really don’t study the TT that deeply, I go in, do my turn, go home.
|
|
|
Post by superteacher on Jul 3, 2010 19:01:27 GMT
Ruislip - we have cancellations during the peak, simply no stock available, though it is nice if the DDM lets us know before you’ve walked all the way into the yard at HAI.. I think there are 5 or 6 WHC – NEP, plus reversers at NOR, DEB, NOA and LES at all times off day or at least there were until tomorrow when the new timetable comes in, haven’t seen what we do on that. I’ll be honest and admit I really don’t study the TT that deeply, I go in, do my turn, go home. There are 6 WHC - NEP trains (101 - 106). There are only 3 scheduled Leytonstone reversers in the evening. North Action and Debden reversers are only scheduled in peak times (although there are some NOA on Sat mornings). As for the new timetable, the off peak services are totally unchanged, even down to the train numbers and times. It's only the peaks / peak shoulders that are different.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 27, 2010 11:33:04 GMT
A new paint job is the only real thing the 92's need. Though I do wonder what the fascination was with beige back in the day. The 313's use that colour as well for some deranged reason. Was drab specified on the statement of requirements?
Reading through the other thread, I don't actually recognise a fair bit of what has been said. I've not noticed the alleged duct tape work? Do different units get operated on different sides of the line? I'm always on the West side.
I've just come back from Paris and once you've toured around on the RER, you'll never complain about the Tube again.
|
|
|
Post by superteacher on Jul 27, 2010 11:49:49 GMT
A new paint job is the only real thing the 92's need. Though I do wonder what the fascination was with beige back in the day. The 313's use that colour as well for some deranged reason. Was drab specified on the statement of requirements? Reading through the other thread, I don't actually recognise a fair bit of what has been said. I've not noticed the alleged duct tape work? Do different units get operated on different sides of the line? I'm always on the West side. I've just come back from Paris and once you've toured around on the RER, you'll never complain about the Tube again. All trains operate over the whole line, there are not separate ones for east and west end.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 13, 2010 11:08:10 GMT
|
|