|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 9, 2021 17:32:44 GMT
Out of curiosity I've gone and bought some 3D printed LU items from Shapeways, this includes some LU signals with the 'pigs ear' - one with feather and one without. It will probably be late January or early February before I see these items, but when I do I'll say more.
Also, I've bought from eBay and a British model railway shop some searchlight style and some Eckon colour light signals. From both places my purchases also include some spare parts ... my aim is recreating the 1932 LMS signals used by Bakerloo line trains on the Watford New Lines and District (plus later, Metropolitan) lines between Bow and Upminster.
For the Watford route I have some photos of the signals, but the Upminster route was resignalled when I was too young to be out and about photographing trains.
Eventually I'd like to have a layout for my purchases. At present though that is not possible - however building things like signals 'now' will expedite the process when it is time to start building a layout. I already have some model buildings from many years ago.
My thoughts are 'present-era' with a twist. We have many historic railway centres where transports from many different generations / epochs can be seen together. Some of these have demonstration lines which often require fully working signals. I might add electric rails too, this being something that is not actually done in 'real life' but I suppose could be done - but only if they are not actually energised!
|
|
|
Post by grumpycat on Jan 9, 2021 22:02:45 GMT
I do want to see photos of when you done these and your layout hope it goes well
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 10, 2021 15:48:04 GMT
As far as I can ascertain, the 'searchlight' type signals akin to the LMS Watford DC lines applied only from Upney eastwards. West from there, apart from semaphores in the Barking area, colour light signals as far as Campbell Road Junction, 'ordinary' main line signals were used (1920s if I recall correctly). The DC style signals from Upney eastwards were a slight variation to the Watford line apparently - I have only seen photos of them at Upminster and Dagenham East. This link might help showing what was where in 1936 www.harsig.org/PDF/District_East_1936.pdf
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 10, 2021 19:55:58 GMT
As far as I can ascertain, the 'searchlight' type signals akin to the LMS Watford DC lines applied only from Upney eastwards. West from there, apart from semaphores in the Barking area, colour light signals as far as Campbell Road Junction, 'ordinary' main line signals were used (1920s if I recall correctly). The DC style signals from Upney eastwards were a slight variation to the Watford line apparently - I have only seen photos of them at Upminster and Dagenham East. This link might help showing what was where in 1936 www.harsig.org/PDF/District_East_1936.pdf Oh, what I've read online suggests that it was all the way to Upminster - but I am too young to know from my own observations.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 10, 2021 21:34:04 GMT
As far as I can ascertain, the 'searchlight' type signals akin to the LMS Watford DC lines applied only from Upney eastwards. West from there, apart from semaphores in the Barking area, colour light signals as far as Campbell Road Junction, 'ordinary' main line signals were used (1920s if I recall correctly). The DC style signals from Upney eastwards were a slight variation to the Watford line apparently - I have only seen photos of them at Upminster and Dagenham East. This link might help showing what was where in 1936 www.harsig.org/PDF/District_East_1936.pdf Oh, what I've read online suggests that it was all the way to Upminster - but I am too young to know from my own observations. Colour light most of the way (with some semaphores in the Barking area) but only Upney - Upminster for the DC line searchlight-type signals.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 12, 2021 19:45:55 GMT
Colour light most of the way (with some semaphores in the Barking area) but only Upney - Upminster for the DC line searchlight-type signals. In many ways this made sense, as the Barking - Upminster dc electrified pair of tracks were a brand new section of railway whereas the four-tracking already existed as far as Barking.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 12, 2021 21:40:59 GMT
Exactly. A brand new section of railway opened around similar time as to the DC lines being resignalled.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 23, 2021 0:44:24 GMT
My Shapeways 3D printed signals have now arrived, plus a few other items, such as train stops and more. This is the page from where I bought these items: www.shapeways.com/shops/the%20forth%20rail?section=Line+Side&s=0 btw, they charge VAT at point of sale so the goods arrived without me being asked to pay import duties / additional taxes or fees! Oh and the box was so lightweight that at first I wondered if it was empty! I only bought two signals as I wanted to see what they were about before even thinking of buying a multiple pack of five. Below is a photograph of the signals laid out on a cutting matt. (I've just realised that the signal backs are upside down!) My initial thought is that white plastic signal heads will let too much light through the sides and back, maybe I will need several coats of black paint and to have the lights 'not too bright'. Perhaps use a resister for 12v but only give them 9v. As ever experimentation is the key. I need to wait for warmer weather for painting - I plan to do this in a garden shed where mess from spray paint wont matter. The person who sells these signals at Shapeways suggested that people buy K&S brass tubing 2.4mm diameter. I first tried to use the brass tubing that is supplied with Eckon signals but I think this is 3mm as it is ever-so-slightly too big. I have now bought some 2.4mm tubing (it only arrived today and was not photographed) and whilst it fits the internal space looks too small for all the wires for the LEDs - especially for signals with feathers! I am yet to try this out. It is suggested that people use 3mm LEDs for the colour lights but something I do not like (it looks horribly unrealistic) is that not only do these lights protrude too much but what protrudes is red and green. Real signals look more black when not illuminated. I suppose that I could get some clear LEDs, but then I would have to wire them up myself and my soldering skills are somewhat basic. So I am thinking of using pre-wired SMD micro LEDs - a few weeks ago I bought some white ones for the feathers and now await arrivel of some coloured versions - red, yellow and green! What I might do is glue them to a thin piece of plastic so that I can ensure that the lights face forwards. I also need to see if I can get the pigs ear opened up enough to let light through. Perhaps a using a very small drill bit or even a safety pin. I am also looking at creating some LMS Watford New Lines signals. I've bought some kits with round signal heads from Eckon and filed off the bottom corners of one signal head - this can be seen in the image below, next to one in original condition. After photographing my work I have realised that the one I've modified is not quite perfectly done - yet. I think I need a hands-free magnifying glass device. Eckon signal packs also come with a sprue containing many other useful parts. Alas, Eckon do not make searchlight signals but I have seen some American signals made by a Chinese company called 'we-honest' on eBay and have bought one (plus extra signal heads) to see if these can be used. Their signals do not have backs, so I might have to improvise with something. Exactly how I will fit the signal heads to the poles remains to be seen. we-honest also sell multicoloured pre-wired SMD LEDs (red / green and red / yellow / green). I await the arrival of my order, it takes 3-5 weeks and the online tracking says that the goods arrived with Royal Mail on Thursday 21st January. But eBay still quotes a delivery window from 27 January to 11th February. I am in a slight state of trepidation with respect of import tax, VAT, etc. Assuming that all goes well I am also looking at the we-honest working traffic signals, with interest.
|
|
|
Post by billbedford on Jan 24, 2021 10:06:36 GMT
It is suggested that people use 3mm LEDs for the colour lights but something I do not like (it looks horribly unrealistic) is that not only do these lights protrude too much but what protrudes is red and green. Real signals look more black when not illuminated. I suppose that I could get some clear LEDs, but then I would have to wire them up myself and my soldering skills are somewhat basic. So I am thinking of using pre-wired SMD micro LEDs - a few weeks ago I bought some white ones for the feathers and now await arrivel of some coloured versions - red, yellow and green! What I might do is glue them to a thin piece of plastic so that I can ensure that the lights face forwards. I also need to see if I can get the pigs ear opened up enough to let light through. Perhaps a using a very small drill bit or even a safety pin. Have you thought of mounting the LED under the baseboard and using glass fibres as light pipes up to the lenses? You may need a diffuser as the lens. <<Rincew1nd: duplicate post deleted>>
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 24, 2021 21:20:07 GMT
Have you thought of mounting the LED under the baseboard and using glass fibres as light pipes up to the lenses? You may need a diffuser as the lens. Years ago I might have done that, but having seen an SMD LED in action I think that these will be easier to implement. Anyway, if the LED power wires wont fit through the brass tube I doubt that optical fibres will fit through. If need be I'll use the brass tube as a shared electrical return.
|
|
|
Post by whistlekiller2000 on Jan 25, 2021 7:56:13 GMT
Have you thought of mounting the LED under the baseboard and using glass fibres as light pipes up to the lenses? You may need a diffuser as the lens. Years ago I might have done that, but having seen an SMD LED in action I think that these will be easier to implement. Anyway, if the LED power wires wont fit through the brass tube I doubt that optical fibres will fit through. If need be I'll use the brass tube as a shared electrical return. In a previous life I installed fibre optic cables for data networks and the actual fibres were a whole lot thinner than regular wires Simon. The ones I worked with most were 50 microns in diameter. Would they run up the tubes OK?
|
|
|
Post by metrofan on Jan 25, 2021 10:35:55 GMT
Years ago I might have done that, but having seen an SMD LED in action I think that these will be easier to implement. Anyway, if the LED power wires wont fit through the brass tube I doubt that optical fibres will fit through. If need be I'll use the brass tube as a shared electrical return. In a previous life I installed fibre optic cables for data networks and the actual fibres were a whole lot thinner than regular wires Simon. The ones I worked with most were 50 microns in diameter. Would they run up the tubes OK? I have had a similar issue and found that 1.5mm Axial LED bulbs were the best compromise. Easily fitted to scale scratch built signals with 5 light feathers.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 25, 2021 20:08:09 GMT
With the fibre optic solution how would the small dot of light be converted to a large enough circle that it fills the signal head? I have used fibre optics in the past (a few decades ago) as it was the only way to add white headlights to a train. In those days white LEDs had not been invented.
The axial LED option also looks interesting, although I might need to improve my soldering skills.
I've found that a small circle of grey anti-static computer component bag looks promising as a way to mask the colour seen on a LED when it is not illuminated. This will help make a signal aspect look 'dark' - rather than see the LED plastic colour. Almost certainly a magnifying lens and tweezers will be needed when placing at the desired location.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Feb 3, 2021 10:49:56 GMT
I must be the first person buying a LU 2 Aspect Kiosk from Shapeways as I keep getting messages saying that they are having printing issues and the person who designed the 3D print has been asked to modify it. Right now it is labelled as 'Not For Sale' on the page at Shapeways www.shapeways.com/product/F4SG32Q8Q/lu-2aspect-kiosk?optionId=60542035&li=ostatusI have now received a Q38 DM from Radley models. It looks good, most of it is plastic, although the bogies are white metal which will need gluing or soldering. They have a fantastic range of models, I will definitely be getting more. What I would also like (but is probably not commercially viable for them to produce) is a Cammel Laird tube train - the ones with the oval windows, similar to F stock.
|
|
|
Post by metroland on Feb 3, 2021 22:06:48 GMT
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Feb 6, 2021 14:03:58 GMT
Its all done now and Shapeways have despatched it to me (along with the rest of my order). I look forward to seeing it midweek. One possible issue is that whilst VAT was added to the final amount charged by Shapeways to my first order, for this order VAT has not been charged. I hope this does not result in delays at customs and extra charges! (The VAT element I understand, although of course no-one actually *likes* paying tax - what concerns me is that the carriers might slap-on their own 'tax collection' fees)
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Feb 7, 2021 10:31:03 GMT
I’ve heard horror stories about hauliers adding extra costs to the order to cover border fees. I’ve been trying to order a D78 car and it’s being blocked due to border issues! Very frustrating!
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Feb 14, 2021 13:02:04 GMT
I’ve heard horror stories about hauliers adding extra costs to the order to cover border fees. I’ve been trying to order a D78 car and it’s being blocked due to border issues! Very frustrating! I'm baffled and alarmed by the border issues, in the event my most recent order turned up a few days earlier than predicted and without any demand 'with menaces' for extra funds. The items I bought include: fog repeaters, rail gap indicators, ticket gates (the version that includes 'end of row gates') and the LU 2 Aspect Kiosk signal that is on top of its box of electronics - see below: The + shaped sprue has the faces for the rail gap indicators, gosh these things are tiny! I need a magnifying glass - or something that I think is called OptiVisor. Apologies for the top and bottom rows being slightly out of focus. I've noticed that the LU 2 Aspect Kiosk is not now included on the index page that shows the the range of LU products and if the direct link is clicked (as seen in a previous message, above) it is marked as 'Not For Sale'. Next month I'll get something else from Shapeways. For London Underground stuff I much prefer to buy from Radley's, as their products include underframe equipment and bogies, plus seating too - albeit for some things at extra cost (ie: the Q38 I recently bought).
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Feb 14, 2021 19:57:36 GMT
I’ve heard horror stories about hauliers adding extra costs to the order to cover border fees. I’ve been trying to order a D78 car and it’s being blocked due to border issues! Very frustrating! out of interest, who (at Shapeways) sells D78 trains? The people who I have seen do not have these trains. The Bluebell Railway sell 3D models of the Ashbury etc trains which they own and sometimes come to London - as far as I'm aware these carriages are not sold by Radleys. www.shapeways.com/shops/bluebellmodelrailwayshop?li=pb
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Feb 15, 2021 22:15:33 GMT
Not seen a D78 on shapeways. I’m going to hopefully have a good at a D stock for Radley Models in the next few months.
I’ve nearly finished the trailer chassis and body. The chassis does come with fitted seats which should help.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Aug 20, 2021 23:08:53 GMT
Its been a while since I updated this thread. Partly because progress has been slow. I never seem to have enough time! Anyway, I still have not built the 'Mind the Gap' tube station - I was searching for some postal tubes which I knew I had in the loft. I will get around to this eventually, but am thinking of making it a recreated tube station located at a transport museum. (The 1825 station at Beamish was relocated to there, brick by brick, so the concept already exists 'in real life'). As no models of gate end stock exist I'll put in a couple of Radley Standard Stock tube train cars. I might modify them to have open doors and people inside. I've recently discovered Kingsway printed stations and buildings and am partway through building some of their designs. For platforms I chose the one based on a 1930s station platform. I very much did not want a Northern line south London style station platform as that has no emotional attachment for me. 2mm square section Evergreen / Plastruct plastic strips painted black can represent the tube style of power rails. I have the Peco power rail chairs. I need to fit lights in the station and have found some 30 mm LED lights which could be used to mimic fluorescent lights. I'd like to have them hang down a little from the platform ceiling but it might be easier to not do this. Having looked at photos of real underground stations I've seen enough varieties to know that whatever I do will be prototypically correct for somewhere. I did experiment with fibre optics of a type designed to leak light along the fibre but the amount of light coming out was too little - its a shame as this would have been an easier - and cheaper - option. This image shows part of a platform. I am hoping that one of the model railway suppliers will make for me the correct LU style of platform edge coping with tactile 'dots' (I have asked but await a reply). Then I can add the rest of the platform and get rid of the white cardboard edge seen here. I also need to add adverts, platform end signs, seats, passengers etc. If available I'll also add platform end barriers. I am unsure what to do about litter bins. The name Hitherton comes from something I bought in the late 1990s when the London Underground Railway Society (LURS) were given permission for members to have model railway station names printed using the correct LT logo. I had to choose a name... and that was all I could think of. That said, Kingsway agreed to use my choice of station name as seen here - but I intend to use some of the LURS signage on 'open air' platforms at this station. As Kingsway do not offer passageways with matching tiles I am looking at using a similarish colour card (full colour / not printed) and printing on it a fine grid. This station will be modern-era, with some heritage elements (eg: way out signs) similar to stations such as Highgate, Gants Hill, etc. For station building I chose Mile End (printed with my choice of name) as its sort of from the right era and does not look too big physically / will easily fit in a row of shops. I need modern ticket machines and if I cannot find them commercially will look to reduce something that I photographed down to a small enough image and then print it myself. I'm building my two platform kits slightly differently to how they are meant to be built - I plan to make part of one platform a fully circular tube and even add the inside tube from a kitchen roll beyond the station so that it is possible to look through the station and see the approaching train illuminating the inside of the kitchen roll cardboard tube. For the other platform, wait and see! (cheat comment - Its only just arrived and I cannot build it whilst using a computer). Just to test the concept I pushed an unbuilt kit by Radley of a Standard Stock tube car plus some track in to a kitchen roll cardboard tube. It looks like the cardboard tube will need cutting and widening at the base, but otherwise it will work. As an aside, the tube car kit is a delight, everything just fits together, even the bogie components. So it should be easy to make. When it comes to painting I will have a choice of three colour schemes - plain red, red with cream window frames or red, cream window frames and blue stripe. This third livery was used on trains that went to all the way to Watford Junction instead of just Elephant & Castle - Queens Park.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Aug 29, 2021 11:51:59 GMT
Oh the value of being able to research things said years ago... I'm looking for paint in the correct 'Cerulean Blue' colour for my Radley Models, a search here at DD has revealed that someone else found just what I'm looking for. This thread: districtdavesforum.co.uk/thread/689/london-underground-colours quotes 'Citadel Dark Angels Green'.
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Aug 30, 2021 20:32:32 GMT
Sadly Dark Angels Green is no longer in production but there are alternatives. See the link with the conversion chart. www.dakkadakka.com/wiki/en/paint_range_compatibility_chartDark Angels Green isn’t a bad option for the ‘blue’ and I have been using it for years. I used to work for Games Workshop some 16 years ago so know the paints pretty well. I would say that a tiny bit of blue added to the mix is about right although at 4mm scale it is debatable how much of a difference it makes on the internals of a vehicle.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 3, 2021 21:09:31 GMT
Thanks for that information - I emailed Phil Radley to tell him that I had discovered a correct colour for the train interiors and now think that I ought to pass on your updated information too.
I am curious about the 'tiny bit of blue paint' which you suggested. Which shade of blue?
I am unsure which colour to use for the seats, especially as these were red and green. Maybe I will use a dark red / wine colour.
This past week I spray painted a grey primer, I did it in the garden and left the models in the shed for the best part of the week, not just to dry fully but also because the paint smells awful!
I now need to test them for translucent-ness. I want to check that when I add internal lighting it does not shine through the plastic body!
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 11, 2021 20:56:30 GMT
More painting today ... I now have a black signal head and base; also discovered that I need silver paint for the metal pole (I'm using brass tubing and also painted it today using an etching primer designed for metalwork)
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Sept 12, 2021 20:42:35 GMT
Can’t remember the blue but anything similar to Ultramarine blue would be ok.
For the seats I think a maroon is about right. The scale is just too small to both with the moquette detail.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 15, 2021 18:08:22 GMT
Can’t remember the blue but anything similar to Ultramarine blue would be ok. For the seats I think a maroon is about right. The scale is just too small to both with the moquette detail. In one of the model railway magazines this month they have a feature about detailing the inside of BR Mk2 InterCity carriages and the person doing this stuck paper that had been printed the correct colours on the seats!
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Sept 16, 2021 19:55:12 GMT
Yeah…life is too short for that!! 😂
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 17, 2021 22:42:10 GMT
Undercoat painted Q38 DM and 1927ts trailer The seating unit for the Q38 needs straightening, I am hoping that placing it in hot (not boiling) water will help here. Ideally I would also like a Q or COP composite trailer. I'm waiting for LTM to finish their working Q stock train as I have no idea of the signage these carried (and the correct colours of the signs). Then the next hurdle will be getting this in OO scale format, as my artistic abilities do not extend to freehand sign writing. Maybe for this taking photos of the signs and printing OO scale size images of these on paper will work (unsure) Now that I have the paints I need I am hoping to find time soon (ideally tomorrow) to start painting the seating units - the insides of the body shells will have to wait until I've done the outsides and this cannot be done until I've been to Halfords to buy the paints for the outsides. With a bit of luck I will get to Halfords this coming week, as (because of the smell) I would like to do my spray painting outdoors and leave the painted models in a garden shed overnight to dry. Ideally this needs doing before the weather turns cold. Station platform lighting fluorescent lighting under construction! This is not quite to scale but once completed will look the part. What you see here is square section hollow plastic tube with 15mm (approx) long brass tube sections (painted with black self etching undercoat) superglued on one side. Plus a temporary use of unpainted circular brass tube which is here to hold what I am gluing in place AND (most important) ensure that it is straight! I used brass (rather than plastic) circular tube because plastic will let light shine through. But I could not also use brass square tube because the circular tube sections might be electrically live and I do not want short circuits. For lights I bought some 3 volt LED cob strip lights on eBay. These are scarily bright! What I plan to do is alternate the electrical polarity of the lights each time, as then I will only need one feeder wire for each end unit (the things which look black here). These feeder wires will power the lights on each sides of the end units. I would prefer to add to each positive polarity feeder wire a resistor for 12v, but am not sure if the resistors will cope with two lights each. My aim is to avoid future accidental blowing of the LEDS by someone giving them 12v instead if 3v. Resistors will be located above the roof, so out of sight - and where there will be enough ventilation to prevent them from overheating. Before fitting the lights I will need to paint everything white. Also slowly coming is the LU signal - the signal head has been painted black and I've drilled out the 'pigs ears' with a manual drill (powered would be overkill) and 0.8mm drill bit. For lighting I am using pre-wired SMD LED lights. These are tiny and to make handling easier I've glued their backs to some black paper. For the front lens I am thinking of adding translucent cereal packet plastic that has been painted black with paint that has been thinned. This will create the right look of darkness when the light is not illuminated whilst allowing the red or green to shine through when required. Something I strongly dislike is LED lights with the colour visible at the front! Thats all for now.
|
|
metman
Global Moderator
5056 05/12/1961-23/04/2012 RIP
Posts: 7,421
|
Post by metman on Sept 19, 2021 13:28:21 GMT
Looking good. You should be able to straighten the seats in warm water. Good luck
|
|