Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,196
|
Post by Tom on Jul 4, 2022 8:20:27 GMT
So do we believe HQ or someone on site? I was on site at South Harrow over the weekend, the signalling is more or less ready (though there is a list of items requiring 'snagging'), but there does seem to be a lack of lighting and the walkways aren't complete.
|
|
Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,196
|
Post by Tom on Jul 4, 2022 8:26:04 GMT
Interesting - because I didn't think Costain had any signalling design capability. On reading the full news release, it look much more like they're doing civils enabling works rather than the signalling design itself!
|
|
|
Post by marri260 on Jul 4, 2022 10:56:30 GMT
Very interesting. Could I please ask for the benefit of someone simple like me, what this will specifically result in, in terms of changes to the actual signalling on the ground / from an operating point of view etc?
Surely this is not anything to do with ATO purely with the lack of funding and company involved - is it more an attempt at minor modifications to the existing signalling, perhaps to enhance the overlaps for slightly higher performance on the new trains where possible?
Again, I can't imagine with the current financial situation that there is any scope for some kind of thorough conventional resignalling either?
Or maybe I completely misunderstand - as I say the article is hard for someone not involved with this kind of thing to draw any specifics or details from.
Thanks for sharing, lots more info on here than via any official channels at work!
|
|
|
Post by 100andthirty on Jul 4, 2022 17:47:05 GMT
marri260: It's an obvious requirement that the driver needs to see the signals. The new fleet introduces a number of changes. Firstly, it is some 7 m longer than the old train and in some stations the train will have to stop with the cab in the tunnel. This means that the driver might not be able to see the starter signal and the signal might need to be moved. Secondly, current crashworthiness standards means that the driver will sit further from the windscreen, and the sighing though the windscreen will be narrower than on 1973 tube stock. Again this might mean signals will have to be moved. Thirdly, at other locations the train will stop further back from the signal so the driver can see it. This might affect how track circuits are cleared, and might affect capacity. The first two really only require engineering capability to lay out drawings/some basic geometry. The third might need some limited signalling knowledge, but with the support of someone like this forum's Tom, Costain would be able to do the rest.
|
|
Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,196
|
Post by Tom on Jul 5, 2022 8:10:42 GMT
My gut feel is that all we're going to see on the Picc for the next few years will be co-acting signals or relocation of signals for sighting purposes, and then a few mods at critical sites to provide capacity improvement at the pinch points - I know King's Cross WB is one such location being talked about.
As I hinted earlier, I wasn't aware Costain had any signalling design capability, and even less so with experience of LU, traditionally a niche market. I wonder if they might engage a subcontractor for the actually signalling modifications and do the civils and other enabling works themselves.
|
|
|
Post by Dstock7080 on Jul 6, 2022 16:19:49 GMT
First '73 Stock W222+205E went into the new sidings at South Harrow at 02.00 this morning, to test operations.
|
|
|
Post by marri260 on Jul 7, 2022 22:14:28 GMT
marri260: It's an obvious requirement that the driver needs to see the signals. The new fleet introduces a number of changes. Firstly, it is some 7 m longer than the old train and in some stations the train will have to stop with the cab in the tunnel. This means that the driver might not be able to see the starter signal and the signal might need to be moved. Secondly, current crashworthiness standards means that the driver will sit further from the windscreen, and the sighing though the windscreen will be narrower than on 1973 tube stock. Again this might mean signals will have to be moved. Thirdly, at other locations the train will stop further back from the signal so the driver can see it. This might affect how track circuits are cleared, and might affect capacity. The first two really only require engineering capability to lay out drawings/some basic geometry. The third might need some limited signalling knowledge, but with the support of someone like this forum's Tom, Costain would be able to do the rest. This I know and is all obvious - I was not aware that the contract for the additional co-acting signals etc that is ongoing in the tunnel sections didn't cover the whole line. As I say, the article is very generic and could have meant a number of things, but thanks for clarifying.
|
|
|
Post by rheostar on Jul 8, 2022 7:15:13 GMT
marri260: It's an obvious requirement that the driver needs to see the signals. The new fleet introduces a number of changes. Firstly, it is some 7 m longer than the old train and in some stations the train will have to stop with the cab in the tunnel. This means that the driver might not be able to see the starter signal and the signal might need to be moved. When we had guards on the '73 stock, motormen had to stop with the cab in the tunnel or the guard wouldn't have been able to open the rear cab door to observe the platform. Don't think many signals will need to be moved as most station starters are a few metres into the tunnel.
|
|
|
Post by nig on Jul 8, 2022 12:09:18 GMT
marri260: It's an obvious requirement that the driver needs to see the signals. The new fleet introduces a number of changes. Firstly, it is some 7 m longer than the old train and in some stations the train will have to stop with the cab in the tunnel. This means that the driver might not be able to see the starter signal and the signal might need to be moved. When we had guards on the '73 stock, motormen had to stop with the cab in the tunnel or the guard wouldn't have been able to open the rear cab door to observe the platform. Don't think many signals will need to be moved as most station starters are a few metres into the tunnel. Most if not all the tunnel sections are getting co acting starter signals quite a few Have already been done
|
|
Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,196
|
Post by Tom on Jul 8, 2022 18:29:33 GMT
Unfortunately as the sight lines on 2024 Tube Stock are much worse than 1973 stock quite a large number of signals have to be moved (bearing in mind that in many cases the starter is on the right and the driver is on the left). Co-acting signals have already been provided at: Earl's Court Gloucester Road Knightsbridge Green Park Piccadilly Circus Leicester Square Covent Garden
and South Kensington is due to be commissioned next weekend.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Jul 13, 2022 3:58:01 GMT
The South Harrow sidings milestone has been delayed by 110 days, due to late delivery of the signal and electrical designs and extended signal installation durations. [TfL Investment Programme report - quarter to 31 March 2022]
|
|
|
Post by nig on Jul 13, 2022 5:00:00 GMT
The South Harrow sidings milestone has been delayed by 110 days, due to late delivery of the signal and electrical designs and extended signal installation durations. [TfL Investment Programme report - quarter to 31 March 2022] Delayed from when as 4 are opening on Sunday and all have seen is rest towards the end of the year
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Jul 13, 2022 5:20:06 GMT
Milestone chart shows sidings due March 2022, now expected June 2022, but is that the first four? Says "We now have a revised programme for South Harrow sidings with the first four roads due to be commissioned in early July and the remaining eight roads to follow in winter 2022" with Winter covering January, February and March 2023!
|
|
Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,196
|
Post by Tom on Jul 13, 2022 6:35:43 GMT
The South Harrow sidings milestone has been delayed by 110 days, due to late delivery of the signal and electrical designs and extended signal installation durations. [TfL Investment Programme report - quarter to 31 March 2022] I must say, and this is no criticism of jimbo, that this sort of reporting is both over-simplistic and rather disingenuous to the teams mentioned. The South Harrow project team had never delivered works like this before and had a very aggressive schedule - it could be best described as optimistic, with a view that activities and durations could be moulded to fit the end date, rather than the activities driving programme and end date. Their initial programme was of 9 months duration; we are now 16 months in and the work is not expected to be complete until December 2022, some 12 months behind schedule. They were told in March 2021 that it was 18-24 months worth of work, and they didn't believe it - they are now seeing this but choosing to suggest the programme slippage is as a result of others, rather than their own unwillingness to listen to those with experience of similar works. Delayed from when as 4 are opening on Sunday and all have seen is rest towards the end of the year The original milestone was to have had all twelve roads re-commissioned (if not re-opened) by 23 December 2021.
|
|
|
Post by alpinejohn on Jul 13, 2022 10:17:40 GMT
I know most people like new things, but in the case of the South Harrow sidings is there really any need to panic if they are delayed by a few months? Presumably LU have already managed to find alternate parking places for all the current rolling stock whilst the sidings are being reworked so is it really a major disaster if that arrangement has to continue for a few extra months?
The last I heard was that the original plan for deliveries of the new Piccadilly line rolling stock had slipped significantly from early 2023 and the first unit was unlikely to be delivered to the UK in 2023 - so does it really matter if they only manage to create space for one extra train at South Harrow by the end of this year?
I realise that even when the physical work is complete, there is still a heap of related installation, testing and training work needed to commission the new points and signals, before the sidings can be fully cleared for use but I somehow doubt that this will delay the actual delivery/storage of the new trains even if the more realistic timeframes now being discussed prove accurate.
|
|
|
Post by Dstock7080 on Jul 13, 2022 10:29:37 GMT
I realise that even when the physical work is complete, there is still a heap of related installation, testing and training work needed to commission the new points and signals, before the sidings can be fully cleared for use but I somehow doubt that this will delay the actual delivery/storage of the new trains even if the more realistic timeframes now being discussed prove accurate. The expansion of South Harrow is also to create space while Northfields and Cockfosters depots have significant work undertaken for the new trains, which has a contract signed.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Oct 5, 2022 6:41:57 GMT
In August, Ark signalling consultancy was awarded the signalling detailed design contract for the legacy signalling modifications to take place on multiple sites across the Piccadilly line. These designs support the required modifications to the signalling system that result from the new train being longer and having different sight lines from inside the driver’s cab.
In August, manufacturing company Hegenscheidt was awarded a contract for the design, manufacture and installation of a new under-floor tandem wheel lathe, which will be based at Cockfosters Depot. This critical work forms part of the overall upgrade to our depots, with delivery being scheduled from July 2023. This supports the decommissioning of existing facilities and start of construction of new facilities across both Piccadilly line depots.
In September, we awarded the concept design delivery contract to engineering company Arcadis which will enable the Lighting Main Project to begin production of seven concept design statements. The completion of these statements will enable the tender package for design and build works to be issued, with this work scheduled to begin in autumn 2023.
[TfL Commissioner’s report - October 2022]
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Oct 12, 2022 7:11:06 GMT
South Harrow sidings paragraph in Piccadilly Line Upgrade paper to TfL Programmes and Investment Committee meeting on 19 October 2022:
|
|
|
Post by brigham on Oct 12, 2022 7:25:11 GMT
The fact that four new sidings have somehow been 'returned to service' doesn't fill me with confidence in the veracity this report.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Jan 25, 2023 4:10:09 GMT
Sudbury Hill substation works are on track, with Factory Acceptance Testing of the DC Switchboard taking place in Prague. Focus remains on the final installation of DC cables at South Harrow sidings, and subsequent testing and commissioning, to enable the bringing fully in to use before the important timetable change set for May. South Harrow sidings power is supplied from Sudbury Hill Substation and without the power assets being in place these works cannot be brought into use.
A total of 75 per cent of stations on the Piccadilly line are heritage or locally listed so we need consent from local authorities to install our equipment. The first heritage planning application was formally submitted for Caledonian Road station in support of the planned One Person Operation CCTV works. [TfL Commissioner’s report - February 2023]
|
|
|
Post by joshua on Feb 23, 2023 21:25:58 GMT
Unfortunately as the sight lines on 2024 Tube Stock are much worse than 1973 stock quite a large number of signals have to be moved (bearing in mind that in many cases the starter is on the right and the driver is on the left). Co-acting signals have already been provided at: Earl's Court Gloucester Road Knightsbridge Green Park Piccadilly Circus Leicester Square Covent Garden and South Kensington is due to be commissioned next weekend. What is the point of adding the new signals if they are going over to in-cab signalling?
|
|
towerman
My status is now now widower
Posts: 2,968
|
Post by towerman on Feb 23, 2023 21:47:30 GMT
Because the trains will be running with conventional signalling when they first enter service.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Feb 23, 2023 23:11:22 GMT
There is no money for new signalling at present, and when there is it will take time to design, install and commission. In the meantime, colour light signals and trainstops will have to do! Technology of more than a century back.
|
|
|
Post by t697 on Feb 24, 2023 5:02:02 GMT
Quite a contrast with the SUP/4LM project where the addition of co-acting signals was always resisted, resulting in some sub-optimal platform stopping positions and sitting back from running signals, the Picc project seems to be fitting co-actors to a huge number of signals. Perhaps the SUP expectation in the 2000s that ATC was 'just around the corner' played too heavily.
|
|
DWS
every second count's
Posts: 2,487
|
Post by DWS on Feb 24, 2023 7:16:13 GMT
t697 What does SUP stand for,I know 4LM is the four lines modernisation project ?
|
|
|
Post by 100andthirty on Feb 24, 2023 7:43:40 GMT
4LM is the project formerly known as Sub-Surface Upgrade or SUP for short.
|
|
|
Post by roverlei on Feb 24, 2023 7:46:55 GMT
There is no money for new signalling at present, and when there is it will take time to design, install and commission. In the meantime, colour light signals and trainstops will have to do! Technology of more than a century back. Having been stuck between the Ealing Common and Barons Court signal on multiple occasions in the past month, I'll confirm that there's no new signalling. Picc service is absolutely dire right now.
|
|
|
Post by cudsn15 on Feb 24, 2023 8:21:47 GMT
It's about as subtle as an elephant in the room that the line is going through "managed decline" - the state of the trains, the un-reliable service patterns, the regular signalling breakdowns...I have a feeling this is more a political position rather than a natural order of things when comparing to all the other lines.
|
|
|
Post by t697 on Feb 24, 2023 16:26:13 GMT
4LM is the project formerly known as Sub-Surface Upgrade or SUP for short. Yes, Sub-Surface Upgrade Project or Sub-Surface Lines Upgrade Project I seem to recall. It was changed to 4LM at one of the 'stop and re-tender the signalling' stages to try to freshen things up and presumably forget the previous one... Also perhaps part of washing 'Metronet SSL' out of the names in the system. Must have cost a bit in re-doing branding etc. but probably not too much against other abortive costs.
Side door to Farringdon station upstairs offices still had a Metronet nameplate in early 2023 though!
Sorry, back to the Picc Upgrade....
|
|
|
Post by notverydeep on Feb 24, 2023 16:33:55 GMT
Quite a contrast with the SUP/4LM project where the addition of co-acting signals was always resisted, resulting in some sub-optimal platform stopping positions and sitting back from running signals, the Picc project seems to be fitting co-actors to a huge number of signals. Perhaps the SUP expectation in the 2000s that ATC was 'just around the corner' played too heavily. Presumably the longer replacememt Piccadilly line trains make adjusting the platform stopping position problematic in some locations, as this would require selective door operation (SDO), perhaps of more than one set of doors, hence co-acting signals being preferred?
|
|