|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 10:47:04 GMT
Until 1970, two early morning Sunday trains were supplied by the Eastern Region, latterly using DMUs, between Liverpool St main line station and Loughton, using the original route between Loughton Branch Junction and Leyton Station Junction. Peter Haseldine kindly supplied a picture he took from the front entering Loughton's centre platform road in the winter of 1967. Can anyone explain the shunting signals LT22B and 23? Picture is here: Peter tells me the blinds of these DMUs did not all feature "Loughton", but they did have "Ongar". Why? Edit by Londonstuff: link fixed
|
|
|
Post by Red Dragon on Aug 30, 2015 10:59:57 GMT
Until 1970, two early morning Sunday trains were supplied by the Eastern Region, latterly using DMUs, between Liverpool St main line station and Loughton, using the original route between Loughton Branch Junction and Leyton Station Junction. Peter Haseldine kindly supplied a picture he took from the front entering Loughton's centre platform road in the winter of 1967. Can anyone explain the shunting signals LT22B and 23? Picture is at onedrive.live.com/redir?resid=3A57A4660877D435!270&authkey=!AAkVuK7qObAWTlI&v=3&ithint=photo%2cjpg Peter tells me the blinds of these DMUs did not all feature "Loughton", but they did have "Ongar". Why? link not working . . .
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 30, 2015 11:29:38 GMT
Link here From the limited view available the unit looks to be a standard Derby cab, so probably a Lea Valley set (later class 125) although here is a photo of a class 116 with an Epping destination blind (at Witham!) Much discussion on London Reconnections about the dmus to Loughton Around 27/28th May "I think the early trains were for Fleet Street printers going home. There were connections to Stratford on the Shenfield trains weekdays. .............. the 2 February 1970 LT timetable has 0505 and 0535 Sundays trains to Liverpool Street Eastern Region Station, arr 0556/0620, returning at 0619/0655 to Loughton, arr 0700/0733. All these trains except the 0655 are marked “Available only for passengers already in possession of tickets” (as is also the 0350 weekdays Stratford-Loughton, arr 0417). All these trains stopped at all stations north of Stratford, and the Loughton terminators had connections to Epping"
|
|
|
Post by superteacher on Aug 30, 2015 11:38:09 GMT
Was there really much demand for these trains? They have always struck me as something of an anomaly.
|
|
|
Post by howda62 on Aug 30, 2015 11:49:21 GMT
I'm afraid I can't answer your questions on the signals, but there was some prior discussion of these trains in this thread.
|
|
|
Post by whistlekiller2000 on Aug 30, 2015 11:51:37 GMT
I was only 5 when these trains stopped running but my Dad did occasionally wake me up to watch them pass on the embankment between Woodford Station and Woodford Junction. As I've said before on here I really can't recall much detail about them to be honest which is odd because I can remember the moon landing in 1969! Thanks for for the link though. Are there any pictures of the DMU on the line from the outside available anywhere?
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 12:32:19 GMT
Whistlekiller, Peter also sent me pics of the DMU at Loughton and departing Buckhurst Hill. I will try to save them to the cloud later today. Were they much used? Quite a lot of railway staff on them, I think. Printers maybe - certainly the 24hr service on the parallel Chingford line was used by them. Bit of a predecessor of Night Tube, perhaps?
|
|
|
Post by decaded on Aug 30, 2015 12:35:44 GMT
22 was a Calling on signal...for a (4 car)train to enter the platform already occupied by another (4 car) train,for coupling purposes. 23 was the final shunt signal for a route out of the sidings complex. Hope i've remembered this right....its been a long time.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 12:51:58 GMT
For Whistlekiller and others! DMU in centre road Loughton Station 1967 here Link 1DMU with Ongar destination departing Buckhurst Hill 1967 here Link 2 All 3 pictures copyright Peter Haseldine. If you want to use, message me and I'll deal Edit: links fixed by Londonstuff. Couldn't see a third link.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 30, 2015 14:32:11 GMT
I think you've transposed the captions - the second one is clearly at Loughton!
Fascinating - the detail is difficult to see - lighting conditions must have been far from ideal that early in the morning! - but the Ongar-bound unit appears to be a "Lea Valley" unit (class 125) - not that surprising in that area, but colour photos of them are rare as they were relatively early withdrawals (c 1975), at which time dmus were not generally considered interesting enough to use photographic film on. (And externally the LV sets looked very similar to the ubiquitous class 116)
the other one though ............ at first glance a bog-standard Metro-Camell class 101, but they were never common in London. But lurking in the shadows is evidence of a valence undxer the buffer beam, and rather more obviously the waist-height jumper cables on the front end, and what looks like a "yellow diamond" coupling code. This is one of the original "lightweight" dmus, most of which were allocated to Lincoln, Norwich and Bacup - but Stratford had two of them. They were all withdrawn by 1968 (The Beeching cuts had resulted in a surplus of dmus, and these, along with the Lea Valley sets, were selected for withdrawal because of their non-standard coupling arrangements). This one is remarkable as the nearer car is in Rail Blue, (with the new BR logo) which only replaced green as standard for dmus in 1966 - the further car appears to still be in lined green. Given their early withdrawal, I am surprised any of them were ever painted blue in the first place, let alone caught on a colour photo! However, it would appear that Stratford were fairly quick off the mark, as the Lea Valley unit is also in blue.
|
|
|
Post by whistlekiller2000 on Aug 30, 2015 14:38:13 GMT
For Whistlekiller and others! DMU in centre road Loughton Station 1967 here Link 1DMU with Ongar destination departing Buckhurst Hill 1967 here Link 2 All 3 pictures copyright Peter Haseldine. If you want to use, message me and I'll deal Edit: links fixed by Londonstuff. Couldn't see a third link.Smashing stuff stapler! Thank you very much for that!
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 15:53:19 GMT
Sorry - third pic is the one I originally sent. Glad you all liked these I have another photo from PH, which was being sent to a local historical journal, which shows in the distance, the set in harlequin form - one car green the other blue. How much better the original looks, IMO! So here is my link to that, for londonstuff to doctor. onedrive.live.com/redir?resid=3A57A4660877D435!273&authkey=!AFCPVtZz8i8FtCU&v=3&ithint=photo%2cjpg PH says he also has a super 8 colour cine film of these workings but no means of digitising it
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 30, 2015 17:22:37 GMT
That Link didn't work - try thisVery clearly half-and-half coloured in that one (the view is from the sunlit side) The valence below the buffers, unique to the first non-standard batch, is also just discernible.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 17:46:34 GMT
Decaded - thanks vm. I'd never have thought of that. This is probably of a relic of the days when it was intended to work the main service from Loughton west, and serve Epping and Ongar by 4 car shuttles - which was never done. Wonder when 23A was abolished?
|
|
|
Post by snoggle on Aug 30, 2015 18:50:07 GMT
Thanks for sharing those photos. They seem ever so slightly bonkers - BR DMUs running over Central Line metals - but fascinating as a piece of railway history.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 30, 2015 19:56:02 GMT
Decaded - thanks vm. I'd never have thought of that. This is probably of a relic of the days when it was intended to work the main service from Loughton west, and serve Epping and Ongar by 4 car shuttles - which was never done. Wonder when 23A was abolished? Shuttles most definitely did run www.lurs.org.uk/articles12_htm_files/2012%2008%20points%20of%20interest.pdf(second article, the first is unrelated) This is what the 1935 stock was used for (although the photo in the article is from shortly after electrification, when standard stock was used). Two car (later augmented to three), rather than four, was the norm.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 30, 2015 21:01:04 GMT
Apologies NF; hadn't realised they lasted till 1957. But Loughton was never, post electrification, the northern terminus for most of the service, as had been intended? The Central Line platform describers all read (pre dot matrix) If no through train is shown, change at Loughton for stations beyond, thus referencing the erstwhile shuttle 30 years after their demise. Probably the reason for this was increased patronage caused by the building of the LCC estate at Debden (which had previously been a station of Blake Hall-equivalent importance) - complete by about 1955, and the 1953-56 Walthamstow Council estate at Epping.
|
|
|
Post by superteacher on Aug 30, 2015 21:06:26 GMT
Apologies NF; hadn't realised they lasted till 1957. But Loughton was never, post electrification, the northern terminus for most of the service, as had been intended? I think in the early days of electrification, Debden was where most of the trains from London terminated.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 30, 2015 23:08:03 GMT
Apologies NF; hadn't realised they lasted till 1957. But Loughton was never, post electrification, the northern terminus for most of the service, as had been intended? The Central Line platform describers all read (pre dot matrix) I f no through train is shown, change at Loughton for stations beyond, thus referencing the erstwhile shuttle 30 years after their demise. Probably the reason for this was increased patronage caused by the building of the LCC estate at Debden (which had previously been a station of Blake Hall-equivalent importance) - complete by about 1955, and the 1953-56 Walthamstow Council estate at Epping. It would appear from the article that Debden was the northern terminus for most of the services from central London , but the shuttles started at Loughton - looking at the layouts, this was presumably to avoid the problems that would be associated with reversing both services at the same station. The reason, presumably, was to save on rolling stock and/or electricity by running short formations on the sparsely-populated section in the Green Belt "The Loughton – Epping shuttle service came into being when the Central Line was extended to Epping on 25 September 1949. During off-peak periods, a limited through service to and from central London was provided beyond Debden to Epping and to ‘double up’ the service to Epping, a same frequency shuttle service with one 2-car train was provided." Each service ran at a 40-48 minute interval, giving a combined frequency to Epping of nearly 3tph! It seems through working increased fairly quickly, albeit with trains dividing at Loughton 9presumabky again to match supply to demand on the outer reaches), so the shuttle was soon cut back, and by 1952 (WTT11) it was only running at weekends.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Aug 31, 2015 10:30:26 GMT
Much more information directly relevant to this thread can be found at this Loughton and District Historical Society newsletter www.theydon.org.uk/lhs/Downloads/LHS%20News%20178.pdfThe article also details a school trip during the morning rush hour where the school children travelled on a non-stop steam train through stations thronged with commuters waiting for Central Line trains to central London. (I wish I'd been there with a camera!!! ) What is perhaps the most amazing thing which occurred during this twilight of mainline trains on this route is what happened between Woodford station and Woodford Junction. At some stage in the early 1960s this section of railway (plus the route through to Hainault) started hosting trials of self-driving trains. Eventually every Victoria Line 1967 tube stock train was used here, prior to (and even after) the opening of the Victoria Line. So, what this means is that BR trains travelled on a section of railway which was also being used by self-driving Underground trains. Certainly this applies to the Sunday diesel multiple units but depending on the time frame possibly also diesel (or even steam?) hauled goods trains - the latter possibly even travelling all the way round the Hainault loop to Newbury Park. What I am not sure about is whether any automatic trains were running at the exact same times of day as the mainline trains... perhaps even passing each other whilst in motion. I feel sure however that there were no no safety cases or other time consuming causes of paralysis by analysis such as are usual 'today'. Simon edit to add: Some photos of first generation DMU's such as those which might have operated over Central Line tracks can be found at the link below. These are seen at Stratford low level in the days when the North Woolwich service was diesel powered, I dont recall for sure possibly this was after they had been extended to Camden Road. Filmed using a 110 camera, so alas a little grainy. citytransport.info/DMU.htm
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 31, 2015 12:11:55 GMT
Yes, the ATO experiment was between Woodford and Hainault, and from memory started in 1964 - when both DMUs and BR type 1 and 2 hauled goods trains were operating as far as Loughton and beyond. So far as I know the whole Loop shuttle service was provided by ATs. Not steam, as Stratford was dieselised before that. ATOs did not operate north of Woodford Junction, nor south of Hainault/Woodford sidings. It was certainly impressive when LT "Caution - automatic trains operating" notices started to appear. We felt we were in the vanguard of progress.....save that the trains were ordinary ones, adapted. Not certain if diesel hauled freight ever reached right round to Newbury Park, but it certainly did in steam days. It was rather odd, especially at night, to come across a J15 simmering away whilst the tube trains flashed past.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 31, 2015 12:58:13 GMT
edit to add: Some photos of first generation DMU's such as those which might have operated over Central Line tracks can be found at the link below. These are seen at Stratford low level in the days when the North Woolwich service was diesel powered, I dont recall for sure possibly this was after they had been extended to Camden Road. Filmed using a 110 camera, so alas a little grainy. The 105 in the first picture is sporting a "Camden Road" destination blind, so is certainly after the "North London Link" was launched in the eighties. Although 105s were certainly regular fare on the North Woolwich line in the late 1970s, when it still ran to Tottenham Hale, I don't think there were any 104s in London until very late in their careers, so I guess thatpicture is also from the 1980s. However, I don't think either class was operated by Stratford as early as the 1960s, so their appearance at Loughton would have been unlikely.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 31, 2015 13:10:52 GMT
"Caution - automatic trains operating" notices started to appear. We felt we were in the vanguard of progress.....save that the trains were ordinary ones, adapted.. The trains in question were, of course, the small fleet of 1960 stock, which were less than four years old when converted to ATO (after it was decided that the production run for the Central Line would not be based on these prototypes but be a simple follow-on from the 1959 stock)
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Aug 31, 2015 21:03:14 GMT
1. NF, didn't this service restart in 1979, not the 80s? Think it was at first called the crosstown link or some such. Presumably Stratford would have had to commission new blinds, as they hadn't run to Camden Rd in DMU days. 2. I think the last time I travelled on the Lea Bridge-Hall Farm line, Oct 1964, when the Chingford Branch juice was shut off for a w/e, it was in a Derby lightweight, 2 x 2-car units. Would that be right? 3. Quite right re the Cravens, but they were hardly revolutionary!
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Aug 31, 2015 21:24:54 GMT
1. NF, didn't this service restart in 1979, not the 80s? Think it was at first called the crosstown link or some such. Presumably Stratford would have had to commission new blinds, as they hadn't run to Camden Rd in DMU days. 2. I think the last time I travelled on the Lea Bridge-Hall Farm line, Oct 1964, when the Chingford Branch juice was shut off for a w/e, it was in a Derby lightweight, 2 x 2-car units. Would that be right? 1. You're quite right, although the intermediate stations opened the following year - I was working from memory. 2. Unlikely, although anything is possible. As far as I am aware neither Stratford nor Norwich ever had any Derby lightweights - the reference I have only gives snapshots in 1960 and 1970.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 5, 2015 23:37:05 GMT
I've been doing a little reading of Underground News, as published by the London Underground Railway Society.
UN632 August 2014 p389/390 talks about diesel trains on various branches, inc Chesham and BR services to Epping, etc. Says that DMU's started to arrive at Stratford in 1956, these had Epping and Ongar included in their destinations. But because the Ongar service was electrified in 1957 so the shuttle remained steam to the end.
The last nocturnal BR passenger DMU ran 5th October 1970, it was a class 125 as used on the Lea Valley lines.
UN600 DEC 2011 p730 says that the 1967 Tube Stock trains first entered service on the Central Line on 21st Feb 1968. This means that they are unlikely to have encountered any goods trains - but they were in service at the same time as the passenger DMU's.
I cant image what ordinary people would be say if the DMU's had still be in service today - that is, after having actually encountered one of them. What I do know is the utterly astonished look on the faces of the unaware passengers (tourists with heavy suitcases who had just arrived in London on a Eurostar train) which I saw at Kings Cross station in early 2013 when the steam train came through. Especially when Met. No.1 was leading!
However, perhaps travelling on the diesels would have been included in the "must do" tick box list for transport enthusiasts?
Exactly how present-day ATO would cope is something I'll leave for the experts to ponder.
Simon
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Sept 6, 2015 10:00:38 GMT
As far as I know ONLY the 92 stock is allowed to run on the Central Line nowadays - the Craven excursion last year was a bit of a one-off. Under the LOIS study of 1997, and Crossrail 2 mk 1, there was talk of reconverting the Epping (Ongar) branches to main line. In the case of LOIS, an extension between Ongar and Chelmsford was proposed. That would involve some re-education after 65 years of 3/4 min headway tube trains. The great public of West Essex would have to rediscover timetables, for one thing!
|
|
|
Post by bassmike on Sept 6, 2015 16:35:42 GMT
Re freight trains round to Newbury Park, I remember reading somewhere that a Southern region class 33 actually made it to N P -reversing in the stub of the line to Seven Kings.
|
|
|
Post by bassmike on Sept 6, 2015 16:38:32 GMT
Probably temporarily spare at Stratford for some reason
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Sept 6, 2015 21:20:57 GMT
As far as I know ONLY the 92 stock is allowed to run on the Central Line nowadays - the Craven excursion last year was a bit of a one-off. Under the LOIS study of 1997, and Crossrail 2 mk 1, there was talk of reconverting the Epping (Ongar) branches to main line. In the case of LOIS, an extension between Ongar and Chelmsford was proposed. That would involve some re-education after 65 years of 3/4 min headway tube trains. The great public of West Essex would have to rediscover timetables, for one thing! Plus the TRC and battery locos (which I often hear passing below my house in the wee small hours). Apart from anything else there is the requirement for special high lift shoegear for the former Central London Railway sections of line. I thought that the Craven train last year was hauled by locos, not powered from the tracks. Certainly when I saw (and filmed) it passing through Leytonstone on its way to Epping it had two yellow locos at each end. Simon
|
|