Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 5, 2006 22:42:37 GMT
This possibly should be moved to a more appropriate section, since it concerns NR staff. Right, I was in a queue at my local station, Brentwood on Monday, getting a return to Romford (but thats not important ), and because I look older, I got asked if I had any ID on me when I asked for a childs ticket. Luckily I had the back page of my passport photocopied for just an eventuality, so I say this to the bloke and he goes '' Yeah, just show it to me '', so I do and he goes ''Yeah, I s'pose your a child'' ( I had my DOB on my passport and I'm not 16 yet!) So anyway, I got my child ticket, but went away feeling very pi$$ed off cos of the attitude of the ticket clerk. Made me think of a question though: Is it up to the customer to prove that they're under 16, and are a child (obviously if they are!), or is it the Train Operating Company's responsibility to prove that they're not ? Also, if I hadn't had any valid ID on me, what would've happened then, if I'd have refused to pay full adult fare? (Just to clarify, I will be 16 in May! )
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 5, 2006 22:48:47 GMT
Made me think of a question though: Is it up to the customer to prove that they're under 16, and are a child (obviously if they are!), or is it the Train Operating Company's responsibility to prove that they're not ? Also, if I hadn't had any valid ID on me, what would've happened then, if I'd have refused to pay full adult fare? (Just to clarify, I will be 16 in May! ) The Onus is on your to check with your local Train Operating Company / LUL etc to see what identification you need. Most companies produce a photocard for younger members of society, and by rights without one of these you cannot gain the particualr discount, even though you may look young / old / male / female..... Even thought it does sound strange, Passports are not accepted as ID for a child ticket If you had refused to pay the adult fare, that would be your problem, and obviously if you were to travel without a valid ticket you would be liable to a £20 fine. Bottom line is, have a read up on the subject, see what ID you need to get, and then go get it, as that way you wont fall into any problems.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 1:00:09 GMT
Yeah, I can sympahtise with you Joe, at your age I looked a little older than I was, and was surprised how rude and unpleasant some bus drivers were. BTW does your avatar represent an alien happy on a good drink? ;D
|
|
Colin
Advisor
My preserved fire engine!
Posts: 11,346
|
Post by Colin on Apr 6, 2006 3:15:05 GMT
Made me think of a question though: Is it up to the customer to prove that they're under 16, and are a child (obviously if they are!), or is it the Train Operating Company's responsibility to prove that they're not ? Also, if I hadn't had any valid ID on me, what would've happened then, if I'd have refused to pay full adult fare? (Just to clarify, I will be 16 in May! ) As I used to work in the ticket office: You do not need any proof of age for a return ticket, you are however recommended to carry an approved photocard to prevent refusal of service. The ticket seller must use their judgement in deciding wether you are entitled to purchase a child rate ticket - the same applies to revenue inspectors should they check your ticket during your journey. If you do not carry an approved photocard when purchasing or using your ticket, you may be refused service (and/or have your ticket withdrawn). The only approved proof of entitlement is a photocard issued by T fL (Oyster) or a TOC. As MA says - you can avoid any bother by having an approved photo card, I know you're close to 16 and it's a pain, but those are the rules. Incidentally, if you're staying in [further] education, you'll need a student/16-17 photocard to get discounts. If you need more info, get a copy of 'the conditions of carriage' from any ticket office (NR and/or LUL).
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 6:47:05 GMT
I've started to use my priv to prove that i'm under 16 (especially on the buses) as my oyster has bitten the dust!
Everyone's ever so much more polite...
Sam
|
|
|
Post by agoodcuppa on Apr 6, 2006 7:42:04 GMT
Why can't TPTB understand that it's this kind of situation that puts people off using public transport?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 7:46:00 GMT
BTW does your avatar represent an alien happy on a good drink? ;D ;D *Chuckling to himself* No, not really - I was just getting bored of having nothing there. I'm gonna get some photo's soon, so I'll put them up, but IMO, having that alien thing is better than nothing!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 9:12:57 GMT
I've started to use my priv to prove that i'm under 16 (especially on the buses) as my oyster has bitten the dust! You need to be careful about that as a Priv ticket isnt valid on a bus. Even thought you are only proving your age with it, some RCIs are likely to give you a £20 fine, as you do not have any valuid ticket. Again the onus is on you to get your defective oyster card replaced.
|
|
|
Post by Tomcakes on Apr 6, 2006 9:59:51 GMT
Hmm. The PTE here introduced a scheme whereby if you were 14-16 you'd get a photo pass which showed you were <16, if you looked like you might be over 16. Now this has been extended down to 10 year olds, who must have a pass to get child fare. Even if they are blatently only 10, jobsworth staff seem to get a kick from getting them to pay the full fare - they know the kid is entitled to the child fare but because they havn't got a pass they won't let them on. Rather than assisting people in confirming their age when its in doubt, it seems to have become a "must-have" for anyone of any age.
When I was down in London a few years ago, a guy at the ticket office demanded identification to allow me to purchase a child travelcard (because, guess what, the machines won't sell you one. How useful when the ticket office is closed.). However when I went away and came back with parents 10 minutes later, he sold me one with no problems whatsoever...
|
|
|
Post by Tubeboy on Apr 6, 2006 10:53:02 GMT
Now that under 11s can go free on the tube i think this will make it harder for gateline staff. I have already come across groups of teenagers where one of them is 16[looks it and has an adult ticket] and he is with what look like 14/15 year olds pretending they are 11 or younger trying to get off paying for them. In my experience a lot of teenagers will try to get out of paying and when i direct them to the excess fares window i get abuse. Friday night is worst, they have no money for a ticket, but have enough to buy drink and get into a club. Of course [like any group in society] there are honest ones and its a shame they are paying for their peers. I think some teenagers realise they can get everything for nothing, they get free bus travel, and they get an allowance for staying on at school post 16
|
|
|
Post by Tomcakes on Apr 6, 2006 11:12:36 GMT
and they get an allowance for staying on at school post 16 Only under certain conditions, based on household income. They also don't seem to recognise that people may be starting the same courses as everyone else but be a few days outside the year group, and hence are told to shove off.
|
|
|
Post by Tubeboy on Apr 6, 2006 11:13:41 GMT
Also lets not forget that free travel for under 11s was a "sweetner" for the removal of the family travelcard. This was withdrawn, again, to people misusing it. usually adults pretending to be children or middle class people buying a reduced rate travelcard[£3.10 for a z12 as opposed to £4.70] and only paying 80p for the child[free at weekends] despite the child being a baby. A child ticket dont forget is from 5 upwards.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 11:18:10 GMT
Not quite LU, but the worst example that I've heard of this sort of thing is Arrivas bus routes around Epping. I was told that on one route, used heavily for school traffic, a child has to carry TWO photo passes. As it passes over the Essex/Herts boundary, and then back again, they have to have an Essex and Herts pass. Without these they would get charged adult fare (as if a school uniform wasn't a giveaway).
|
|
|
Post by Tomcakes on Apr 6, 2006 11:30:04 GMT
Even worse is when you have to pass over a country boundry and neither council can decide who pays for your child rate travel, so you end up paying an adult price .
|
|
|
Post by Tubeboy on Apr 6, 2006 11:33:13 GMT
That seems a bit unfair alex! lets not forget at the end of the day it is all down to discretion, which i know a lot of station staff use. Incidentally when our ticket office is closed and the machines are playing up we let people go on the mainline route from my station without tickets.We phone the station concerned, give the customer our name and yet the staff at their destination are itching to penalty fare them etc etc
|
|
Phil
In memoriam
RIP 23-Oct-2018
Posts: 9,473
|
Post by Phil on Apr 6, 2006 11:42:08 GMT
A school uniform and a pass is no deterrent to the 'bus pass out of the window to a mate' syndrome.
However, unless the law has changed in the last few years we were told NEVER to refuse travel to a kid that looked younger than a teenager. Because if the kid then got abducted, run over or whatever, the transport company could be held wholly responsible (as did happen in one case)
Tubeboy and MA etc have obviously been given company instructions, but I hope to goodness they are in writing. If one was to refuse a ticket to a 10yr old trying to get home at 2130 and he left the station and got picked up by a *£$#&!^...., that booking office guy would need a very good lawyer and excellent union advice.
I suppose the only difference these days is that most kids have mobile phones, but the technology doesn't yet let the parent send the cash for the fare down the phone....
|
|
Colin
Advisor
My preserved fire engine!
Posts: 11,346
|
Post by Colin on Apr 6, 2006 11:47:35 GMT
Let's be fair people, ticket sellers, revenue inspectors and gateline staff are told "these are the rules, go enforce them". I've had to deal with parents, stroppy teenagers and all that.......yes the system isn't perfect, and yes some staff are over zealous at times - but at the end of the day all staff have to abide by the conditions of carraige (bus companies do have something similar, especially on council contracted school journeys). As has already been stated, the only gauranteed way of getting child fares, is to have the relevant photocard. Wether that's right or wrong would probably make another thread in it's own right - but those are the rules. On the subject of the baby having a ticket, yes they go free up to the age of five - but only if they do not occupy a seat. If said baby is in a 'car seat' for example, and that is placed on a seat, a fare is payable. Similarly a toddler/child of 2,3 or 4 years, if occupying a seat, should have a ticket. Infact when I worked in the ticket office, all ticket sellers would actively encourage people with kids under 5 to buy the family travelcard. Why shouldn't they have explioted the rules and saved a few pence? Edit: Phil and a few others posted while I was typing - Phil is absolutely right - if you're obviously a kid, and you have no money or an invalid ticket, the instruction is better safe than sorry...........................trouble is, too many kids know that policy only too well
|
|
|
Post by Tubeboy on Apr 6, 2006 12:08:15 GMT
obviously i have a duty of care to my customers and would not refuse to let a child travel. similarly a woman late at night with no money. however like you said there are lots of people willing to take advantage of that fact. As for people paying a few pence less its not so much a money issue, its the fact they are demanding it, little realising its the staffs discretion that is giving it, as officially they are not entitled to it. My point is they were getting a 1/3 off while everyone else is paying full whack.Not fair
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 6, 2006 12:46:38 GMT
That seems a bit unfair alex! Yea I know. I was a bit surprised when I was told about that bus route. The fares aren't cheap in that part of the world either, someone was telling me a four mile journey cost them £4.80 I'm not sure if this is a single or return, but by bus it's still a lot. A few years ago you could get a Stagecoach bus, unlimited journeys all over the south of England for a mere £4.40
|
|
|
Post by ttran on Apr 29, 2006 12:57:16 GMT
I turn 16 in May as well and have been questioned by ticket sellers and ticket inspectors on numerous occasions about my age in recent years.
One very nice (not common!) ticket inspector told me about some 'proof of age' card, which apparently is to prove that you are really under 16, in the event you look older.
Anyway, these days us school students who catch buses all have Tcards and these have the D.O.B on 'em. Comes in handy I tells ya...
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 30, 2006 0:57:07 GMT
Used to get this when i was in me teens! Would be buying a ticket at a BRITISH RAIL station as it was then [!] and I'd get the ticket seller ask me abruptly "Whats your date of birth" I'd get all sarcastic and say summat like "third of the second, Eighteen Sixty two, what'd ya think eh?"
tap tap tap on the ticket machine and I gets me CHILD ticket.
|
|
|
Post by Chris W on Apr 30, 2006 7:16:12 GMT
When I work in the city getting off at Moorgate (now I've changed jobs earlier this year, this now happens about 1 week in 4) I've seen on a couple of occasions as I've approached the ticket barriers, an adult going through having put their ticket in with CHILD briefly appearing on the machine.
I know when U16's evade its bad enough (they may be trying to impress their peers), but to me an adult doing it is 10-times worse as the adult should know better...
The characters were long merged into the rush hour crowd by the time I got to the barriers....
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 30, 2006 12:27:59 GMT
Well guys,
I was on a photography trip around December. I didn't take much money because i brought along a packed lunch. "It's cheaper you know". Anyway, i wanted a drink so i spent the pound i brought along for the purpose. Now i must of droped my ticket as i got the money out as when i got to the station it wasn't there.
Go back into mcdonalds, can't find it. So 10 mins go by and it's 5.30 on a dark cold evening in London. Phone my mum on my mobile and she said go to the ticket office and see if they can help. Phone me back straight away afterwards.
So i go up to the ticket office and explain. So he asks where i live, Upminster. He goes blimey right, goes into his pocket punches up a single to UB and says there you go. I say thank you i will pay you back.
Get home phone mum at work, everything is fine. Late January i go back to Charing Cross. I don't see him, go back a lil later and there he is. I gave him the money back and thanked him.
If he hadn't done that i would probably be writing a much longer story!
James
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 1, 2006 9:06:32 GMT
Well guys, I was on a photography trip around December. I didn't take much money because i brought along a packed lunch. "It's cheaper you know". Anyway, i wanted a drink so i spent the pound i brought along for the purpose. Now i must of droped my ticket as i got the money out as when i got to the station it wasn't there. Go back into mcdonalds, can't find it. So 10 mins go by and it's 5.30 on a dark cold evening in London. Phone my mum on my mobile and she said go to the ticket office and see if they can help. Phone me back straight away afterwards. So i go up to the ticket office and explain. So he asks where i live, Upminster. He goes blimey right, goes into his pocket punches up a single to UB and says there you go. I say thank you i will pay you back. Get home phone mum at work, everything is fine. Late January i go back to Charing Cross. I don't see him, go back a lil later and there he is. I gave him the money back and thanked him. If he hadn't done that i would probably be writing a much longer story! James When I was a bus driver, I would always do the same as the guy at Charing Cross. I'd rather be a few pence short than have something horrendous on my concience.
|
|