Where be this to?

I'm still gonna differ. There IS a girder bridge in the Sudbury Hill photo. It's staring you in the face!! Also I know that Northfields was rebuilt on the other side of the road circa 1932 and the original station demolished. Now It MUST be Sudbury Hill as there is no station beyond the bridge where South Ealing should be!

From left to right, I see in the picture you posted a brick wall with an advertisement hoading, wicket gates, the original wooden Sudbury Hill station building, and some pale and space fencing. And in the foreground, a road. I do not see a girder bridge.


If it is Sudbury Hill, please explain LT Museum pics U924, U1990, U1991, U2858, U3635, U3636, U4140, U4534, U4997, and U5755, many of which show a nameboard declaring the place to be 'Northfields and Little Ealing'.

Or alternatively, show me a pic of the Sudbury Hill platform canopies.

Russ

I'm really kicking myself over St James's Park. The more I looked at it, the more I thought was - but I wasn't sure if it had always been in tunnel. Your 'Morning Guv'nor' clue sealed it for me, but, as I did'nt want to look stupid I kept quiet . Just goes to show a stab in the dark could've made me look the dogs testicles ;D ;D

As for the other picture - i'll accept Sudbury Hill Q8. I wasn't born till 1975, so I can't call you a fibber (not saying you're...........sod it, where's me JCB ;D). I based my choice on a picture in the book 'Going Green, by Piers Connor (bottom of page 40). There's a (poor) copy of it in the link below - i'm sure you would agree, the canopies are identicle.

images.fotopic.net/ydamdf.jpg

Now you've confuddle me Russ. I was talking of the platforms whan I said that the bridge was a girder but now you say I opined it was the road way picture. I all of a tizwas now. Night night all!

One other thing before I go. I think you'll agree that the line east of Northfields is exactly flat. However on the Sudbury Hill photo the track dips slightly under the bridge and then gently rises into the distance. As it does at Sudbury Hill.

Now the garden photo posted by Russ is undoubtedly of Northfields as the bridge gives it away. (BTW it's NOT a girder bridge. It's the wooden panelling of the footbrige you can see)

I have just been looking at the Picc line DVD and in it you can clearly see the gentle rise of the track east of the station. As the old photo also shows the same rise I still say it is Sudbury Hill.