|
Post by stapler on Jan 8, 2016 22:25:43 GMT
Does anyone know where the railway scenes for this 1958 MGM/Ealing film were shot? The prison from which the anti-hero escapes is allegedly adjacent to a station, through which an ex-LMS 2-6-0 heads a freight, working tender first. The station looks as if it might be GE in origin, and possibly near a junction. I thought of Millwall Junction, with the prison wall being in fact a dock wall, but surely that was derelict by 1958? Not on reel streets. Also interesting for Bridget played by a youthful Dowager Countess of Grantham
Thread title amended by superteacher for clarity.
|
|
|
Post by revupminster on Jan 8, 2016 23:59:06 GMT
Could have been done on the isle of dogs. The prison gates is a matte painting. The dock walls such as the East India Docks were there until the seventies.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 9, 2016 11:06:41 GMT
ImDb gives it as studio (MGM Borehamwood), Selfridges & Covent Garden.
Looking at the opening sequence, the wooden sleepers on the tracks highly reflect the moonlight/floodlight, which is unusual, because it's usually the rails that would do that-hence how Goering's lot navigated their way towards London from Dover etc.
In the abandoned(?)station, look through the broken window towards the end & you'll see an intact wooden filing cabinet; the two do not juxtapose in a neglected or abandoned station.
I think it's all studio-there's no fencing on the side nearest to the prison wall & there appears to be a platform on that side, too, so how would they stop trespass with just an embankment? Even a broken fence should be there.
The car, reg LFE 2, is authentic! Registered at Lincoln CBC in May 1957.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Jan 9, 2016 11:10:07 GMT
I don't think it can be a studio - that is a very real train running through it. The locomotive 43019 was allocated to Cricklewood at the time, which suggests the Midland Main line, or the Tottenham & Hampstead (Goblin) or perhaps the Dudding Hill line might be the places to look first. That high retaining wall is very distinctive. would expect the top of the wall to be the boundary of railway property, hence the absence of any fencing-off of the far platform. www.abandonedstations.org.uk/Goblin.htmlIt could be Highgate Road Low Level station (on the spur connecting the Goblin to the MML). The station, clearly derelict in the film, closed in 1918, but the line remains open to this day. However, I can find very few photos of the area. The car, incidentally, is a Ford Zephyr convertible - both the car and the registration LFE 2 would be highly desirable today. The convertibles tended not to last very well as the absence of a roof made them structurally weaker. If I were planning a prison breakout I would use something a bit less conspicuous.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 9, 2016 12:24:25 GMT
I don't think it can be a studio - that is a very real train running through it. The locomotive 43019 was allocated to Cricklewood at the time, which suggests the Midland Main line, or the Tottenham & Hampstead (Goblin) or perhaps the Dudding Hill line might be the places to look first. That high retaining wall is very distinctive. would expect the top of the wall to be the boundary of railway property, hence the absence of any fencing-off of the far platform. www.abandonedstations.org.uk/Goblin.htmlIt could be Highgate Road Low Level station (on the spur connecting the Goblin to the MML). The station, clearly derelict in the film, closed in 1918, but the line remains open to this day. However, I can find very few photos of the area. The car, incidentally, is a Ford Zephyr convertible - both the car and the registration LFE 2 would be highly desirable today. The convertibles tended not to last very well as the absence of a roof made them structurally weaker. If I were planning a prison breakout I would use something a bit less conspicuous. According to JE Connor in Middleton Press's London Suburban Railways St Pancras to Barking,ISBN 1904474683, Highgate Road HL was demolished at some point before the 1940's, as the photo therein of ex-WD 2-8-0 63173 receiving attention from a crew member in the late 1940's indicates. Whilst the LL platform remains were, according to JE Connor, swept away along with the covered footbridge connecting LL & HL in the 1930's. For the Dudding Hill Line, London's Disused Stations Vol 7, Connor & Butler publications, by JE Connor, ISBN 9780947699422, the Dudding Hill station buildings weren't demolished until 1989, despite the last passenger train calling in 1903!!! There is also an embankment on the other platform side, which would fit the bill, too. As would the curve in the line as it enters the station. Unfortunately, there is no evidence whatsoever for a platform canopy of any sort at Dudding Hill from at least the time of passenger closure, so unless they added one for the film, that rules it out. Equally, to illustrate that curve in the rails correctly as they enter the station, the two platforms at Dudding Hill are the wrong way round. Unless, of course, there's another distinctive rail curve leaving Dudding Hill, over to you, Norby, because I don't have a photo of that end to confirm or deny. Harlesden, t'other station on the Dudding Hill chord, had its' station building/ticket office on the road bridge over the railway, so that's of little help, unless they built a whole station for the film. Possible that other early closures roundabout those parts like Haverstock Hill might fit the bill, I'll read up later. Agree regarding the getaway car-unless he's going to flog it for cash to finance life on the run. Because the Harry Corbett in the credits isn't the man associated with Sooty, it's Harold Steptoe's Harry H Corbett in an earlier guise.
|
|
|
Post by John Tuthill on Jan 9, 2016 12:46:27 GMT
[According to JE Connor in Middleton Press's London Suburban Railways St Pancras to Barking,ISBN 1904474683, Highgate Road HL was demolished at some point before the 1940's, as the photo therein of ex-WD 2-8-0 63173 receiving attention from a crew member in the late 1940's indicates.
Whilst the LL platform remains were, according to JE Connor, swept away along with the covered footbridge connecting LL & HL in the 1930's.
For the Dudding Hill Line, London's Disused Stations Vol 7, Connor & Butler publications, by JE Connor, ISBN 9780947699422, the Dudding Hill station buildings weren't demolished until 1989, despite the last passenger train calling in 1903!!!
There is also an embankment on the other platform side, which would fit the bill, too. As would the curve in the line as it enters the station.
Unfortunately, there is no evidence whatsoever for a platform canopy of any sort at Dudding Hill from at least the time of passenger closure, so unless they added one for the film, that rules it out. Equally, to illustrate that curve in the rails correctly as they enter the station, the two platforms at Dudding Hill are the wrong way round. Unless, of course, there's another distinctive rail curve leaving Dudding Hill, over to you, Norby, because I don't have a photo of that end to confirm or deny.
Harlesden, t'other station on the Dudding Hill chord, had its' station building/ticket office on the road bridge over the railway, so that's of little help, unless they built a whole station for the film.
Possible that other early closures roundabout those parts like Haverstock Hill might fit the bill, I'll read up later.
Agree regarding the getaway car-unless he's going to flog it for cash to finance life on the run. Because the Harry Corbett in the credits isn't the man associated with Sooty, it's Harold Steptoe's Harry H Corbett in an earlier guise.[/quote]
And I'm looking at the "Britain from above" web page, hopefully we'll find the answer!
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 9, 2016 15:13:11 GMT
Thanks for all this. I remember Highgate Rd just after this time - don't think it was that. Millwall Jc I remember about 10 years later, by when it was just platforms. There is a picture of it in 1954 in Edwin Course's London Railways facing p111 which looks right (including canopy) but no sign of a wall! Wouldn't know about Dudding Hill, though 14A locos were seen on and around the dock lines on transfer freights.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 9, 2016 15:23:17 GMT
Thanks for all this. I remember Highgate Rd just after this time - don't think it was that. Millwall Jc I remember about 10 years later, by when it was just platforms. There is a picture of it in 1954 in Edwin Course's London Railways facing p111 which looks right (including canopy) but no sign of a wall! Wouldn't know about Dudding Hill, though 14A locos were seen on and around the dock lines on transfer freights. Here's the photographic evidence of Millwall Junction through the ages (thanks to Subterranea Brittanica/Disused Stations & Nick Catford photography): Millwall JunctionNote, in the link, there's an opportunity to click here for further photographs on the bottom of the page.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 9, 2016 15:41:33 GMT
Thanks BF. There are walls about, but perhaps not in the right place?
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 9, 2016 18:51:57 GMT
Thanks BF. There are walls about, but perhaps not in the right place? But there are walls at one of the termini Millwall Junction once served, Blackwall-thanks again Nick Catford & Subterranea Brittanica~: blackwallI know there were a large number of freight depots around there, too, lingering long after passenger closure at MJ & co. I wonder if there was a Midland Railway one still extant in 1958, which would explain how 43019 ended up in East London for the shoot?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 9, 2016 20:17:57 GMT
A suggestion here that it's Kew Bridge
|
|
|
Post by John Tuthill on Jan 9, 2016 20:30:24 GMT
A suggestion here that it's Kew Bridge You just beat me to it.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 9, 2016 20:36:10 GMT
A suggestion here that it's Kew Bridge Looking at this, from Middleton Press's Willeseden Junction To Richmond by Vic Mitchell & Keith Smith isbn 1873793715: might be the answer-same curve, same canopies on the platform & not too far from Midland railway territory!!
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Jan 9, 2016 23:25:58 GMT
I hadn't thought that far afield, since almost everything in that area had at least three - if not four! rails. Indeed electric trains from Broad Street served those platforms from 1916 until the service was suspended indefinitely in 1940. (this was the rump of the original route to Richmond, via Kew East Curve and the long-gone Barnes West curve, superseded by the direct route via Gunnersbury in 1869) The 3rd and 4th rails must have been removed sometime in the subsequent 18 years. This is the same scene today www.google.co.uk/maps/@51.4896517,-0.2869398,3a,15y,350.43h,84.23t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sv_BK1ZvYF8WDjUiMABb_Jw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656!6m1!1e1 Was the high wall built for the scene then - or was there something taller there in 1958?, Would have been very handy for Ealing Studios, but in fact the film, despite being made under the Ealing name, it was made at MGM's studios in Elstree.
|
|
|
Post by John Tuthill on Jan 9, 2016 23:38:47 GMT
I hadn't thought that far afield, since almost everything in that area had at least three - if not four! rails. This is the same scene today www.google.co.uk/maps/@51.4896517,-0.2869398,3a,15y,350.43h,84.23t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sv_BK1ZvYF8WDjUiMABb_Jw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656!6m1!1e1 Was the high wall built for the scene then - or was there something taller there in 1958?, Would have been very handy for Ealing Studios, but in fact the film, despite being made under the Ealing name, it was made at MGM's studios in Elstree. Brentford Market was about there, could be an external wall? As the station was closed, would have been ideal for the film companies use.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Jan 10, 2016 0:23:31 GMT
Here's an aerial view of Brentford Market - the wall does look quite high. www.brentfordhistory.com/wp-content/uploads/Brentford-Market-c1970.jpgThe caption says c1970, but it must be about forty years older - the Chiswick flyover is missing which puts it prior to 1959, but the presence of the Great West Road means it is after 1925. There are things looking suspiciously like tramlines in the streets, which dates it to before c1935 (by which time trolleybuses had taken over the routes through Brentford). The LM platforms of the station don't look as dilapidated as they should if they had been closed for thirty years either! There also appear to be buildings surmounting it along part of its length, which correspond to the lit windows seen above the wall in the film.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 10, 2016 9:32:11 GMT
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 10, 2016 10:24:35 GMT
Sorry, but I can find no reference to any station called Brentford Market, can anyone provide more info, because Kew Bridge clearly fits the film's opening titles apart from the wall, which could be a studio shot spliced in?
If it's Brentford Dock you speak of, I've got a March 1958 photo and the trackwork there is far more complicated than as sen in the film. Plus it was operational until 1970.
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 10, 2016 12:03:28 GMT
No - it's the eastern side of Kew Bridge people have identified. Brentford Market, the building, was adjacent.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 10, 2016 12:56:26 GMT
No - it's the eastern side of Kew Bridge people have identified. Brentford Market, the building, was adjacent. Cheers, thanks for that heads-up, afraid Brentford is about as familiar to me as Brentwood! Now, what about the prison used?
|
|
|
Post by nickf on Jan 10, 2016 14:45:19 GMT
This is the entry I found in Horton's Guide to Britain's Railways in Feature Films (ISBN 978 1 85794 287 3)
Nowhere to Go GB 1958 Ealing, Director Seth Holt. George Nader, Maggie Smith. A thief escapes from prison but gets no help from the underworld. The opening scenes were filmed at the old LMR platforms of Kew Bridge station on the Kew Bridge-Willesden Junction line, with a freight train hauled by an Ivatt 4MT 2-6-0 No 43019. Later there are scenes filmed at Marylebone with a 'K2' 2-6-0 visible on a GC line service.
|
|
|
Post by John Tuthill on Jan 10, 2016 15:51:58 GMT
This is the entry I found in Horton's Guide to Britain's Railways in Feature Films (ISBN 978 1 85794 287 3) Nowhere to GoGB 1958 Ealing, Director Seth Holt. George Nader, Maggie Smith. A thief escapes from prison but gets no help from the underworld.The opening scenes were filmed at the old LMR platforms of Kew Bridge station on the Kew Bridge-Willesden Junction line, with a freight train hauled by an Ivatt 4MT 2-6-0 No 43019. Later there are scenes filmed at Marylebone with a 'K2' 2-6-0 visible on a GC line service. Well done, I think you've cracked it!
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 10, 2016 21:50:15 GMT
Documentary evidence indeed; many thanks! What about the train, though? A train of empty coal wagons - some 50 - going *south* from the South Acton direction onto the east facing SR line? Why would you do that? Coal traffic from the Midlands, yes, but they would have been full wagons... Why take empty wagons into London or south of the river? Perhaps Michael Balcon prevailed on the LMR to run a train of empties in a sort of circle especially for the camera? I hope BR charged a hefty facility fee for what ended up as a B-movie.
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 10, 2016 23:00:28 GMT
Documentary evidence indeed; many thanks! What about the train, though? A train of empty coal wagons - some 50 - going *south* from the South Acton direction onto the east facing SR line? Why would you do that? Coal traffic from the Midlands, yes, but they would have been full wagons... Why take empty wagons into London or south of the river? Perhaps Michael Balcon prevailed on the LMR to run a train of empties in a sort of circle especially for the camera? I hope BR charged a hefty facility fee for what ended up as a B-movie. The credits on the front don't acknowledge it-can't get the full movie on YouTube to check the end credits, but thought we might as well share Dame Maggie a-pouting in her Renault Dauphine;and yes, the TUC registration ran from February-December 1957 in London CC.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Jan 10, 2016 23:40:40 GMT
... Why take empty [mineral] wagons into London or south of the river?. Just possibly going to the Kent coalfield, Betteshanger or Snowdown. Dame Maggie a-pouting in her Renault Dauphine;and yes, the TUC registration ran from February-December 1957 in London CC. She controlled that tail-slide well at the end of that clip (a common problem with rear-engined cars)
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 11, 2016 8:18:14 GMT
Kent coalfield? Bit of a long shot? Also a mixture of wooden and steel bodies, so unlikely to be a train of either new or condemned stock. I have the film recorded and will check the end credits
|
|
|
Post by arun on Jan 11, 2016 12:22:39 GMT
Possibly not a long shot - I recall reading recently that the Kent coal field was actually, if not quite discovered by, certainly intensively dug and run by companies owned by the LC&DR and SECR.
Arun
|
|
|
Post by stapler on Jan 11, 2016 12:51:49 GMT
There are no end credits, just "The End" and "made at MGM British Studios". So no credit for the LMR. Arun, I know the Kent coalfield was rail-dependent and the SR was involved with it. Just doubtful that a train of empties would be run round that curve in that direction!
|
|
|
Post by theblackferret on Jan 11, 2016 13:37:35 GMT
There are no end credits, just "The End" and "made at MGM British Studios". So no credit for the LMR. Arun, I know the Kent coalfield was rail-dependent and the SR was involved with it. Just doubtful that a train of empties would be run round that curve in that direction! Right, I wonder if, as the scene was filmed at night anyway, whether they actually filmed this on a semi-official basis? How busy would that stretch be with freight and would there be the need, as used to be the case on the Kent commuter lines, for most freight to run overnight, because of the lack of available train paths during the day? If all was clear by, say 19:30, how difficult would it have been for the signal box controlling that line to keep it clear for an irregular movement or three, particularly if the freight train in the film had finished work for the day and was anyway due to stable nearby overnight? It could also be the filming was done on Saturday & Sunday nights, because I think most of the freight produced from Saturday morning working (still widespread amongst blue & white-collar workers in 1958) would have awaited pick-up by train on Monday am. I don't think the BR staff would have taken part in that without management approval, but I wonder if the management just told Ealing Films/MGM to go ahead and pay the railwaymen approved BR overtime rates, once they were assured the train movements presented no danger.
|
|
|
Post by norbitonflyer on Jan 11, 2016 13:43:41 GMT
There are no end credits, just "The End" and "made at MGM British Studios". So no credit for the LMR. Arun, I know the Kent coalfield was rail-dependent and the SR was involved with it. Just doubtful that a train of empties would be run round that curve in that direction! It could have been going a long way round from Cricklewood via Dudding Hill and Barnes to get to the West London Line and thus Wembley. May be more convenient to go round the houses than reverse at Acton Wells and again on the WCML at Willesden. It obviously wasn't going far, if they didn't think it worth turning the loco round to run chimney first. Mineral wagons can carry minerals other than coal. Although the south east is not well-known for mining, there are some big chalk quarries in the North Downs - notably near the Quarry Line itself!
|
|