|
Post by Dstock7080 on Apr 11, 2023 15:42:23 GMT
probably inevitable with the ongoing rolling stock shortage:
WTT18 M-F peak 57 trains TTN87/23 M-F peak 52 trains
|
|
|
Post by david123 on Apr 13, 2023 22:47:39 GMT
Why can't they just buy more trains? or those type of trains can not be made now?
|
|
Chris M
Global Moderator
Forum Quizmaster
Always happy to receive quiz ideas and pictures by email or PM
Posts: 19,407
|
Post by Chris M on Apr 14, 2023 1:26:27 GMT
There are multiple reasons why they can't just buy more trains for the Jubilee line - 1. They aren't made any more and all the tooling to make them will have been discarded and the machines put to use making much newer trains 2. TfL doesn't have the money to buy new trains at the moment 3. You can't just buy tube-gauge trains - they are a bespoke product designed and/or customised for each line so new trains would need to be designed, developed, built, tested and approved - this would take 4-5 years at absolute minimum, and more than likely longer, even if they had the money in hand 4. Any new trains that have different door spacing to the 1996 stock would require a complex and expensive programme of replacing the platform edge doors. The new trains being built for the Piccadilly line have different door spacing.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Apr 14, 2023 2:28:39 GMT
An earlier plan for a build of 27 modern day equivalent trains, 10 for the Jubilee and 17 for the Northern Line, avoiding problems with platform edge doors, training and maintenance etc, finally came to an end in 2017 when tenders exceeded budget provision.
|
|
|
Post by roman80 on Apr 14, 2023 14:39:37 GMT
At current estimates, when will the fleet be back to full size post repairs?
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Dec 28, 2023 20:02:52 GMT
As the year ends, still no answer to last post and the problem continues! Have we any explanation as to what the problem with the trains is, and how and when it can be overcome? I ask because TfL recently published FOI-2935-2324 which asked when will the frame fatigue cracks be fixed, and will this improve the service? The answer is that temporary fixes are monitored, and permanent fixes will be completed by 2027, but these are not the cause of fleet shortage problems! I suppose another FoI enquiry will be needed to reveal what the actual cause is! Don't the travelling public deserve an explanation for all their troubles, as the Central Line users have finally received? link
|
|
|
Post by xtmw on Dec 28, 2023 20:27:00 GMT
Brilliant work there jimbo! I think the word I am looking for is shocking. It is shocking that TfL haven't communicated a reason to passengers on why there is a shortage of trains. We all know the reason why but I won't go into it. What are the cancellation figures for the Jubilee line lately? TfL have been reporting a 'good service' for the past few days/weeks (apart from other service disruptions) but you're better off asking anyone but the official status page.
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Dec 29, 2023 1:27:12 GMT
December 2023 Underground News has an article "LU State of Poor Repair" based on Programmes & Investment Committee meeting on 5 October 2023 which says: Deferred overhaul of the Jubilee Line fleet has meant that train availability regularly drops to around 80%, when 90% of fleet is required to operate the full timetable. That suggests that the problem arises from an economy measure to defer planned rolling stock overhaul, although exactly what part is crucial is not revealed.
|
|
bigvern
Posts: 1,022
Member is Online
|
Post by bigvern on Dec 29, 2023 13:25:41 GMT
A report on the GLA states back in March:
"The Jubilee line fleet was due to be overhauled in 2020 but this was deferred as a result of the pandemic, with works beginning in September 2022. Since February 2023, TfL has seen an increase in parts required to be replaced, but the war in Ukraine has led to difficulties sourcing parts from Europe. To mitigate the impact of this, TfL is working closely with its supply chain to increase availability of materials. TfL is working to address the fleet issues that have contributed to recent performance issues on the Jubilee line."
One item that is a constant spares issue on all lines are provision of replacement wheelsets (and has been for many years), whilst wheels are reprofiled they cannot go below a certain size before issues occur with the car heights and the critical level of the underside of the gearboxes on track crossings. Many other items are required during a heavy overhaul programme, where traction and door components are replaced, the supply chains for parts is very complex and often there are no other parts providers for bespoke parts and where a big order is underway for an overhaul, materlals becomes an issue for the suppliers.
The underframe cracks may have some impact, but the shortages of critical running items as wheelsets, especially in the autumn where wheelsets are turned more frequently due to wheel damage, and as train fleets come due for wheelset replacement at Overhaul, many of the trains have small wheels so cannot run beyond wheel scrapping size and the trains have to be taken out of service, Im sure wheelsets have been moved around to keep other units in service, but without parts arriving on time, the problems will get worse.
This is also impacting the Overhauls of the S8 stock and the 09 stocks currently.
Also the building of many new trains around the world currently is using the resourses required for spares provisions.
|
|
|
Post by d7666 on Dec 29, 2023 17:47:55 GMT
shortages of critical running items as wheelsets, especially in the autumn where wheelsets are turned more frequently due to wheel damage, and as train fleets come due for wheelset replacement at Overhaul, many of the trains have small wheels so cannot run beyond wheel scrapping size and the trains have to be taken out of service, Enter stage left a Jubilee RAT.
|
|
|
Post by spsmiler on Jan 1, 2024 14:21:25 GMT
Why can't they just buy more trains? or those type of trains can not be made now? I recall how some C Stock cars were bespoke built in Eastern Europe! Nicknamed C85 stock!
|
|
|
Post by jimbo on Jan 1, 2024 15:22:07 GMT
Wikipedia says that following the 2005 London bombings, two trailer cars were rebuilt from the frames upwards as C08 stock, although I believe this was only a nickname. Also a two-car unit was rebuilt in part, thus providing another train for service. link This was therefore a very restricted project, mainly concerning trailer cars. Not a basis for constructing additional trains for service. The precedent for that was the project for additional modern equivalent trains, which came to an end in 2017 as uneconomic. link There were proposals to boost the Northern line with new trains, releasing trains to boost the Jubilee Line. The last 2020 proposal was for a new fleet for the Jubilee to release the current trains to boost the Northern Line with a split service, link p.31/44 which was a shovel-ready project which failed to achieve support with the on-going Covid crisis reducing ongoing demand for the foreseeable future. Make do and mend seems to produce a better economic case than a new fleet!
|
|
|
Post by d7666 on Jan 2, 2024 4:34:30 GMT
I recall how some C Stock cars were bespoke built in Eastern Europe! Nicknamed C85 stock! Please explain.
|
|
|
Post by Dstock7080 on Jan 2, 2024 6:55:56 GMT
jimbo did explain in the post above that the two cars were colloquially known, by a small minority, as C08 Stock. I don’t believe this was ever used in official circles.
|
|
|
Post by d7666 on Jan 2, 2024 21:10:34 GMT
jimbo did explain in the post above that the two cars were colloquially known, by a small minority, as C08 Stock. I don’t believe this was ever used in official circles. I was asking about "bespoke" and "eastern bloc" neither of which has been explained. One message from jimbo does refer to rebuild, not bespoke build, and nowhere does it say where, never mind eastern bloc, so it reads like it was something else. Especially as "the eastern bloc" ceased to exist from about ~1990 onwards which was way before the events of 2005. Therefore it all read like a different group of cars. Hence my question. So what was the "eastern bloc" connection and are we talking about rebuilds of 2005 damage - or builds or rebuilds of something else ?
|
|
Tom
Administrator
Signalfel?
Posts: 4,100
|
Post by Tom on Jan 3, 2024 18:00:35 GMT
The only person who has used the phrase "eastern bloc" in this thread is you, from what I can see. Other posters have used "Eastern Europe".
The additional C stock cars were new bodies (I believe everything below the solebar was reused) manufactured by Bombardier at a factory in Hungary. I would interpret the "bespoke" phrase to mean that they were two 'specials' manufactured using the original drawings, rather than a a large batch or a new fleet.
|
|